I've seen mac smugness quite a bit (and boy are those commercials with bug face jason long annoying). Like one guy at work has macs and is like "oh windows is awful" blablabla. Other people are like "OMG macs are SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO much better! OMG I can't believe how much better they're so much better, windows sucks!"
Now, I like macs and might get one someday. But I fully realize the extra price is more for luxury, good apple tech support, nice build design, thinness, brandname recognition etc and I realize that some programs are faster on mac.
But all the smugness, is it just really from people who are buying into hype?
-
-
I have used only PCs in the past until I needed a mac to run Logic. I have witnessed FAR more hate directed toward mac than windows.
Financially, I dont think it's that uncommon for macs to be the better investment. Unless a person is completely self sufficient with computers, IE knows where to go with problems, knows how to trouble shoot issues independently, etc, then I feel that it is entirely worth the extra money for the fact that
a) chances are you're getting a more solid computer prone to fewer problems
b) The tech support is reliable and if you get a warranty you KNOW that your money will be well spent. A trip to the nearest mac store is quite a bit more ideal than waiting for Dell to send you the mailing box to use, and then waiting however long it takes them to fix the problem (hopefully!) and send it back to you. Not to mention subjecting yourself to their horrendous customer service.
and c) The resale value will be infinitely higher than anything you could hope for with a 2+ year old PC.
When time becomes an issue akin to money, I feel that one finds that the sheer ease of use and reassurance that if something screws up, you're covered, is more than worth the extra few hundred bucks you spend on something as important as a computer that you're going to be using for at least a couple of years.
Sure, if you know enough, with a bit of luck you might be able to get away with the 800$ laptop that serves you equally well and saves you money, but that's not the reason that people buy macs. I honestly havent experienced the smugness. No one I have encountered is willing to compare Macs to PCs, failing to acknowledge the money factor.
It's more the PC users that have such a dislike for Apple that they refuse to acknowledge that the extra money that goes into a mac is actually for more than a pretty toy with bells and whistles.
That being said, I despise the commercials as well. It's marketing for a less than savvy target audience, but what can you do? -
When I calibrated the battery the first time, it took me more than 5 hours before my macbook finally shut down, whereas I've read that running windows, the battery may be able to last 2 or 2.5 hours.
For those that want power efficiency, portability, great tech support, and a good OS, I think Apple is a great choice.
On the other hand, Apple does have its own culture which I feel is very snotty, and it's unfortunate. I too have seen the smugness amongst the community. It's great here, but at other forums, especially macrumors, it's pretty bad. Apple plays into that culture, tries to create a coolness factor, to separate itself from the rest. It's all marketing, and an ingenious plan IMHO, it's brought them a lot of revenue, a lot of people that have switched to Mac (like myself) in recent months/years. So much so, that Microsoft have felt the need to create their own ad campaign to help win consumers back. Isn't competition grand?
All in all, I think you can be a Mac owner, without conforming to the culture. Do I think they're better computers than regular PC's? That's hard to say. Without OS X, and given my past experience, I would say NO. I had to return mine several times because the tech that repaired it kept damaging it, but finally Apple let me do an express exchange, and I got a brand new, updated model in exchange for my broken one. Can you say the same about Dell, or HP, or others? In nearly every case, even if yours is just a month old, they will send a *refurbished* unit. I had mine for 4 months, and I still got a brand new one in exchange. They really seemed to go the extra mile to correct the issues I was having, and for that they've won a customer for life. -
Actually, I think the smugness goes the other way around. For example, stroll through this specific MAC OS X forum and see how many Windows trolls come in to start trouble.
Now review all the other forums on this board and see how many of us Mac users go out of our way to go to ALL the other windows forums to start trouble.
See the difference? -
masterchef341 The guy from The Notebook
There are many smug people in this world.
Some of them have macintosh computers. Smug people should be banished, but instead they preach about macintosh for free, so that Steve Jobs doesn't have to pay to market his own product (but he does anyway).
Windows is awful, but if you want to play *most* PC games you need it. Sometimes, people also get stuck relying on microsoft technologies, which forces them to stick with windows. Microsoft technologies are not all bad, but I stand by my claim that windows by itself is no good. Linux (its still free) and OSX are both great alternatives that everyone else should be using, but unfortunately many still do not.
Windows is not designed for the *light* computer user. In all seriousness, the most recent versions of Ubuntu cater better to this crowd. Mac OS X has a wickedly simple and sensible user interface, and also caters well to the casual crowd. All three operating systems are maintainable and can be satisfactory for power-users.
The most common reverse smugness you see revolves around the concept that windows is for people who "really use computers". It's insane and unfounded logic. The same kind of insane logic that Apple uses when, in an ADVERTISEMENT ON TV THEY CHOOSE TO MOCK MICROSOFT FOR SPENDING TOO MUCH MONEY ON ADVERTISING! This is in the FAMOUS, and famously expensive Mac vs. PC ad campaign.
my point? never believe the hype. everyone is hypocritical and mostly just trying to preserve their purchase decisions in their own eyes. so just make informed decisions.
that is all. -
-
jackluo923 Notebook Virtuoso
https://help.ubuntu.com/community/MacBookPro
You'll need to modify the OS of course.
-
I use both Windows XP and OS X, and tell my friends/relatives to buy Apple without hesitation.
If I exude any smugness, it's usually because they often rattle off some epic story about a windows crash or viruses or registry problems or spyware or their OS slowing down over time. I might be smug when I shrug and say 'none of that happens to me'. I can't help it, I think the 'smugness' is just that people using Mac realize they have found something better than Windows.
The real value in buying Apple is OS X, a UNIX based OS. In my mind it is easily superior to anything Microsoft has released. The quality of the hardware is like a nice bonus. I'm not smug based on the belief that using a mac helps my 'image', it's just that I now look at my friends and their constant windows battles and feel smug knowing I made the choice that means I NEVER have to deal with those issues again. -
-
There are going to be haters on both sides of the camp. There are pros and cons to each OS. Use whatever you feel comfortable with and stick with it. Or do what many of us do, run multiple OSes. Just stick to what you want and what makes you happy and ignore what other people think or say whether it be a Mac or a Windows based laptop.
-
I think yes, there is an inflated hate of Windows (not just from Mac users though) and love of Mac
. I am a supporter of Mac and love Mac OS X, but Windows is not a "failed OS". It has its bugs and faults, I agree, and I prefer Mac OS X to it, but it is not a completely bad OS.
Again, what do I prefer? Mac OS X. But do I hate Windows? No, I don't.
-
I don't think Windows is useless but I do use the word HATE when describing it. I wouldn't call my hate of Windows inflated, I just had a worse experience than others. I think it comes down to a company being able to back up the hype they produce. Apple does a good job backing up the hype while for me Vista never gave me the "WOW!" that MS advertised. If I come across as smug when discussing Windows its simply that I'm still mad about the experience I had with the OS.
-
I've personally seen the smugness of Mac owners, and enjoyed it tremendously! It's just hardware and software people! It won't change your life or enlighten you. I remember a kid in a crashpad (commuter apartment) where I stayed briefly. He had a very nice macbook, I had a nice MSI laptop. He was incredibly pleased with his choice as MacOS was totally superior in every way to windows. So I fired up Macos on my MSI Laptop. The mac owner was not amused. Priceless!
Anyway, I now own an Aluminum Macbook. I love the hardware. It is without a doubt, one of the most well engineered and built laptops available. I love it! And, I mostly run Win7, just to be contrary. Love the Hardware, MacOS is JUST OK, Win7 is very good and the smugness hasn't crept in yet. -
i love both. they both have their advantages and disadvantages, no os is bug free.
-
I'm quite smug tbh.
My mac makes me a better person than those around me. -
The "mac hates pc" or the "pc hates mac" is silly to me. I have friends and know people who are on both sides of the fence and are ready to go to arms for their camps when called for duty. It gets that serious. Whenever my friends or my coworkers get into it, I just wanna head towards the grocery store, buy 2 dozen eggs and maybe some watermelon, go back to the battlefield and throw the eggs and watermelon at them.
I mean, come on are you guys really gonna be smug, hate, or look down upon someone else just because of what type of computer they're using? -
-
People usually gloat when they are in a better position/better product. And the other/opposite side always takes it as being smug or negative since it doesnt benefit them.
For example, if were both into the stock markets and my picks in the last year paid a dividend of $100,000 and you only made $1,000, its a fact I did better and when if I tell you how much I made you would think it was being smug/gloating whatever you want to call it but I'm sure its all negative feelings.
We all know that people pay a premium on macs for the so much better overall quality/ease of use/superior software that you get. Maybe people think that mac users are being smug because they can afford a mac over a pc?
The usual argument comes from people that attack macs are, "I can afford one but I just dont want to spend that much money on the same thing I can get with a pc." To me its just another way of saying, I do have the cash for the mac but it will leave me poor in the end and no more money for other stuff I want.
In the end it doesnt matter, the USD will crash by next year and sadly all americans will be sent to the poor house with hyperinflation...
I'm getting ready and getting diversified out of the us dollar, are you?
Its only a matter of few years left before the US bond market bubble bursts and our fake economy will evaporate and we will see the true debt that we are in.. -
I liked my Mac as something different, but I personally wouldn't say OS X was significantly better than Windows, even Vista. I wouldn't pay extra for a Mac. I don't value the tech support as much as others because I usually figure things for myself. While they look better than a lot of notebooks, that's not a prime motivator for me personally. Perhaps if I wanted a 17" machine, I may value the lightness of the 17" MBP. I like ThinkPads with their timeless design, but they're admittedly low on style.
The other issue for me is that you're paying significantly more for a Mac, but you're not getting proportional value in return in my opinion. For example you'll pay $2k for a MBP, but getting a screen that's not significantly better than anything else on the market. At the end of the day if someone else likes Macs and wants to get one, that doesn't take anything away from me. -
-
.... -
Even overpriced I'd still get a mac. But if they were all the same price, no brainer. -
Yup. -
My "smugness" is showing badly tonight as I'm helping my father install Windows updates. 4 updates (350+ mb) available, everything downloads, 3 updates install and require a reboot. The system restarts and loses the last update so it needs to download 340+ mb again. Funny thing is that the first 3 updates are included in the 4th (Service Pack 2) but MS still forces you to install them first. I can't help but feel happy I switched to a Mac when things like this happen. Oh, I almost forgot that the fans on his Dell could be heard 20 feet away because they are spinning like crazy even though all the system was doing was downloading the updates. My wife asked what all the noise was and I had to remind her that when she had a Dell it did the same thing.
-
i bought a mac because the hardware is near unbeatable (style and speed) and i refused to use vista. Basically, I can game on my windows side and be proficient when working on my mac side.
-
But can we say things like calling the Iphone the Jesus phone, taking the smugness a bit too far?
-
i love how u guys say the hardware in macbooks is superior when its no different from the components in other PCs
-
What's different is the product design approach, and some people neglect to look at it like that.
It's like comparing car brands, the concept is the same and the hardware components work very similar if not, the same. However, the attention to detail to build that product, implementation and functionality is a whole different thing. -
Even so, the build quality and the way OS X handles the hardware is completely different.
I've actually done a test with an audio app I use (Propellerhead Reason) on my Mac and a Windows machine with a really big project I'm working on (25GB+), same hardware, the Windows machine could barely play the project. Audio was skipping and CPU usage was through the window.
My Unibody MBP had no problems bouncing the project at all.
My conclusion here is even though you can find a similar (or exactly) spec-ed Windows machine, chances are (just like in my case) where people's specific needs will be better met by the Mac rather by the more inexpensive Windows machine. -
Unless you plunk down on an alienware for $5-6k for the intense gaming sessions, the macbook pro/dell whatever, asus whatevers all have the same internals/performance with macs having the superior software of course.
I think software is more important than hardware imho. Hardware is important as well but I think software implementation is much more important. I would rather use a generation older chipset if the software is incredible as to a bad/decent software + latest and greatest chipset. -
The self-contradicting Windows users don't help, but Apple's insistence on pushing the thermal envelope for starters means that when the chips are down (i.e. worked hard) means that pro-targeted Windows machines of similar price, or even slightly cheaper, usually perform more solidly.
In terms of build 'quality' such as it is for Apple, the Rev.A issue is very much real and I defy anyone to disprove that. Can you name any other manufacturer with a Rev. A issue?
I think also the Apple Fanboy's insistence on comparing relative reliability with something that's usually less than half the cost, or worse still - something that he built himself in the belief that he is able to throw together a reliable PC - contributes to the justifiable derision aimed at them by many Windows 'fanboys'.
-
To answer the OP's original question, yes its bs. If you're smug about what computer you use, you haven't considered all the individual variables and preferences involved in purchasing and owning a computer. -
-
-
I can't really comment on the variability or basic competence of users. Only platforms.
Personally, apart from the applications problem I think OS X is a very decent OS when considered purely as an OS. It certainly has some standalone advantages over the Crazed Monkey Dancer's current, PR-deficient offering - although I also feel that when the entire app ecosystem is concerned, Vista is a more productive OS - and that even when also considered purely as an OS, it is currently not appreciably worse than the Cupertino-Than-Thou offering.
That is, if you aren't a smug Apple-worshipping (insert expletive of choice)
I do have considerably more to say about the hardware that each OS runs on, but that's another story. -
It really amazes me that people put so much emphasis on factors that have absolutely no relevance to the actual use of a product. A possible public perception of "smugness" does NOT prevent a person from using a computer to do their work in any way shape or form.... unless your only using the computer as a fashion accessory.
If a Mac suits your needs well then get one... if it doesn't then don't. But if your only concerned that someone might laugh/categorize/think your smug for your choice then perhaps it might be better if seek some guidance from a self-esteem book to learn methods for coping with bullies.
There is no requirement to sign up as an apple fanboy when you by a Mac, you can avoid forums, and put a sticker over your apple sign if you must. They say ignorance is bliss.
a
-
The smugness... there's quite the bunch of arrogant fools who can barely discuss the basic technicalities but still claim superiority... these people give all Apple users a bad name. -
-
That was definitely smug. Sorry.
And why aren't the people who descry Apple manufacturing ineptitude not doing the same for their PC counterparts. Why not condemn Clevo for their apparent inability to keep HD's cool in the Sager 8662 case?
And I guess Apple's working on the LED iMacs -
Honestly, I believe that it all depends on a person's experience with the OS, as well as that person's perception on what an OS should be able to do and how he is able to tolerate the short comings of an OS.
A typical pc gamer would, no doubt, usually go for Windows for their custom built rig, because the main thing that they'd be doing is gaming on the system. In some cases, people who are more literate in computing would dual boot their system with Linux/BSD/Unix based OSes (or just run it without Windows), just because they need the extra fluidity and power via open source programs and tools.
Mac OS, as a system platform on its own, offers user a hassle free (somewhat) environment. Most software that one would use, generally comes bundled with it, unlike Windows. However, it'd be folly to say that it is without its fault, just as Windows would crash, Leopard does the same from time to time.
Some would disagree, saying that it has never happen to them before, but not all are as competent as others when handling computer systems. Experienced Windows users who know the ins and outs of Windows, can avoid system crashes and solve generic errors quickly. Same goes to those who are experienced with Mac.
The only experience I've ever had with Mac OS is when I'm maintaining labs filled with Macs. I'm more of a Linux/Windows user, I juggle between the both and I can say that, it all depends on the user, if he just want things to work, Mac might suit him well, or, if he's an avid open source supporter, Linux/BSD might suit him well (Mac as well, because some people don't have the time to debug anything and everything that comes up), finally, windows for those who like the whole 'my computer' environment, as well as the numerous amount of software available for it, be it useful or useless, that's another story.
So yea, OP. I think you'll feel right at home with a Mac, since it's what you want, heck, even you mentioned that 'some' programs run faster than windows on Mac, I guess you did a little research and that means you're going to be using those programs alot, so why not?
-
Apple III only there to illustrate that this isn't a sudden occurence. Read up on cooling systems and Jobs. Only when he originally left the company could the engineers do what they wanted to do... instead of insulting me, I don't know, look into what we are talking about? Also... what do you know of my qualifications?
Oh, but they do... thinks like the M1330 build quality, for example. But you don't see it here. Why? Because it's a discussion whether you are truly paying for absolutely superior design. PC gripes are elsewhere, and guess what? There's more, because, guess what, you can't even compare the amount of PC models to how many Apple has duked out do date. But you won't see anyone come into an Apple forum complaining about their X460's touchpad placement or the hinges on their Y510, will you?
You're even more smug. I'm sorry. That's enough for this thread... if you want to continue this, do so in a PM.
Back to the topic. The Apple ads really don't help with your average Windows user's perception of the average Apple user with their play on stereotypes... then again, isn't the 'smug type' a stereotype in itself, just like the 'jealous Windows guy'? -
There is a really good word people use here...it sounds something like this- [obijnik]-those word is used who,for example,loose card game and start-"oh,you play was pathetic,you were just lucky",or were offended and start acting like a child and things like that... And this topic is like full of those people...
P.S. name any company,and I ll find lots bad things/defects/etc. about their products...
P.P.S EnterKnight,
P.P.P.S this thread needs to be closed since it is pointless...it's like gamer convincing someone who plays only tetris to get nVidia 280gtx... -
@ Enterknight:
Look I was being intentionally smug...this is a thread about smugness afterall, and I intended my post to be lighter hearted than perhaps it was perceived. If you were to see most, if not all my other posts, you'd find that I am extremely centrist when it comes to computers. It irks me when either side makes unsubstantiated claims. A spit in the face insult was not intended...more like a jab to the ribs.
So to the points that were brought up, I think your statements about cooling were simply not nuanced enough: Jobs despises cooling, I mean come on...I am aware that he has a penchant for reducing cooling and noise, but your inclusion of the Apple III as an example seemed to be an attempt to demonstrate a pattern that developed 30 years ago and that is still being perpetuated today. And that simply isn't true. Since you use a desktop as an example, what about the towers? Mine is exceptionally well ventilated.
As to the the Mbp, the only assumption that I made about your qualifications were that you were not A) an Apple engineer or B) an engineer that has thoroughly tested the thermal properties of the Mbp. I feel pretty safe with those assumptions. If I'm wrong, full apologies. Barring my error, who is to say that there is indeed a physical design flaw in the Mbp. Could not the overheating issue, as some say they have, be solved by a firmware fix which lowers the temperature threshold for the fans to spin up to a higher rpm? If there is an issue then can't it just as easily be seen as a software issue?
The part about the Sager...my whole point is that I think you'll find it extremely rare for a Mac owner (excluding fanboys, who I think are far and few between on these forums) to go to the Sager, Dell, HP, etc. forum and complain about that brands build quality, yet PC people come to the Apple forum and comment on them all the time. Lastly, "absolutely superior design" is, in the end, largely subjective.
Back to you regularly scheduled thread....
I've had way too much free time on my hands today. -
I remember the days when a Mac user (such as myself) would bring my iBook into my local coffee house and I would get "THE STARE" of, "You don't belong here". I've had PC fans tell me to my face, "How could you buy that thing, there's no software for it and nobody buys those little Mac things anyway"! -
I'm smug. I have a mac and a proper one at that (powerbook 12").
On the other hand, I'm smug because I'm an elitist. I look down on everyone. -
-
Well there you have it OP. You asked the question and you got many answers. So I am going to close this before it all goes south.
Johnny T - NBR Moderation Team
Mac owners, tell me the truth.. the smugness.. is it just BS?
Discussion in 'Apple and Mac OS X' started by lottdod_1999, Jun 2, 2009.