Thinking of a MB

My son really wants to purchase a MB, mostly for Garageband and other software. My concern is I'm not sure it's worth the money. Top of the line MB $1499, has no dedicated graphics and 5400 HD. I currenty own a Asus notebook w/ 5400 HD and find it very slow moving from task to task and also when I start it up. We just use the Asus for basic stuff, surfing, word, excel, minor gaming, rollercoaster tycoon etc. I know the MB OS is supposed to be so much better, but personally I have not had much problems with windows, at this point I just can't justify moving up to a MBP to get the configuration I would like when I can spend 500 less and get a windows system, probably the T61.

Thoughts??????

 

If you get a macbook, I'd suggest not getting the "top of the line" black one since you're actually paying $125 just for the color. You can get an equivalently configured white macbook (just upgrade the middle model to a 160gb hard drive) for $1374 which you'll probably find a little more reasonable. If you can live with the 120gb hard drive then you'll save an additional $75, which brings you to $1299.

The truth is you'll always be able to find a pc notebook with similar specs for less money, but the configurations I mentioned above will help bridge the gap a bit.

As far as your concerns about the graphics and speed of the hard drive, OS X isn't nearly as power hungry as Windows (especially if you're talking about Vista). If you don't plan on doing any real gaming, the integrated graphics does just fine. If you're near an Apple store, I'd suggest going in and playing around with their models to see for yourself.

 

I think the MacBook is worth its price, and so is the Thinkpad T61.

The 5400 HD isn't much of a problem if you ask me. I haven't noticed a difference between my laptop HDD and my desktop HDD.

If you enjoy the feel of Mac OS X, and like the designs of the Macs, then go with Mac. But if you'd rather get a equally (or more) powerful PC laptop for the same price, go with the Thinkpad.

 

Well, I guess I can give MB a try. It's mostly for my son. I just hope he doesn't run into a lot of compatibility issues with windows and our home network. Thanks.....