W5F vs V6J

well im trying to get everything in one package, portability, power, and style

i like the style of both but i like the size of the W5 better, would there be any consequence of getting a w5 w/ a 2.0 duo and 1.5gb of ram or should i just get a V6J and updrage that one to a 2.0 w/ more ram

all answers are appreciated

 

They are extremely different, but theres pro's and cons to each, and ill list those.

Starting with the V6J

v6j is 15" SXGA regular aspect / core duo 1.66 / dedicated graphics / 1 gig ram / 5.73 pounds

Clearly the specs on this laptop are far superior to the W5F, but your sacrificing a good deal of portability. Granted, it is a better screen, and its pretty thin, it will be far harder to carry around, but you will be able to game with it somewhat.

Now to the W5F

12.1" WXGA screen / 1.66 core duo / 512 ram / integrated graphics / slightly under 4 pounds

Now, the specs are not nearly as good: lacking a gig of ram while the graphics card falls far short of the v6j. However, it is a featherweight laptop, that will be a breeze to carry around.

In conclusion

You need to consider what is most important: performance / graphics or portability. Each of these two are top notch builds, but very different.

A very popular alternative that provides the best of both worlds is the ASUS W3j or A6jm. They both have 14.1" widescreen with killer specs (better graphics / processor than v6j) in a smaller package.

w5f is 12.1" widescreen

 

well i duno if il be gaming too much but i duno, i probly will actually

but cant u just configure a w5 to have a 2.0 duo core plus 1.5 gbs of ram to make it faster?

lol sorry im an asus newby but im definetely going to buy one.

 

Both W5 and V6 models are Ensembles - shipped at a specific configuration by Asus. There are a few resellers out there that offer modifications to customize an Ensemble, but you lose all warranty service provided by Asus; all service under warranty would have to be sent to your reseller.

Check the Asus Notebook FAQ on the main page for links to resellers - you'll have to do some work to find those that offer Ensemble customization, unless others will post direct links for you here.

 

What games are you going to play?...if we are talking about solitaire or the like then you can go ahead with the w5f...but if you are talking about the latest and greatest shooter or mmo you are going to need the beefier graphics card. CPU and memory are not nearly as important to being able to play a new game as the GPU. The larger v6j or the midsize w3j are the only things that are going to play new games at a decent pace.

 

if i get it configured am i risking any problems or complications w/ the quality of my notebook? i dont mind losing the waranty much if im getting more speed out of it but im worried i might lose quality in the notebook itself

iv found a few resellers that will customize it for me btw

 

The notebook is still made by Asus, so the build quality is great. Otherwise, you're only talking about swapping components out, so any potential for complications or problems depends on 1) quality and warranty of the replacement parts and 2) quality (technical expertise) of the person/company doing the "rebuild". The other thing to keep in mind is that upgrades to the hard drive speed or processor will generate more heat as they consume more power, etc so your notebook will probably run (and feel) warmer as well as have the fans running more to compensate for this. 2.0 Duo in either unit is probably overkill, especially in the W5 with integrated graphics - you'll barely (if at all) notice a difference compared to the 1.66 for the vast majority of applications, but the benchmarking will be better.

Asus engineers these things and sets the components specifically for the tolerances of the Ensemble cases - anything above stock will run hotter (but still functional, and you will not have to worry about overheating to the point of causing shutdown) and will be noticeable, especially in the V6J because of its very thin case. So, if you're picky about warmth you may want to reconsider customizing an Ensemble

 

thanks alot for everything guys. iv decided to get the vj6 for the better graphics since i probly will be gaming. im still debaiting whether to go 2.0ghz or not but iv decided on a v6j

thanks again

(o and btw heat doesent bug me at all)

 

You cannot go 2.0 ghz with the v6j. All of those models are premade with specific parts that cannot be customized.

Again, if you are looking at gaming, check out the w3j. It has better graphics, faster cpu and a smaller screen (you were looking at an ultra portable before).

But to be honest, it doesnt sound like you have done enough research, I would highly recommend you spend some more time to weigh all your options.

 

i can take the v6j to 2.0, i can even take it to 2.16. there are a few resellers out there that will do the modifications such as http://www.agearnotebooks.com/

 

right, Moose you can at that site, but have you checked the W3J??

ASUS W3J:
14" WXGA
Thin and light, 5.7lbs
X1600 256mb
1.8ghz
1gb of ram

The GPU is the most important thing for gaming, so the X1600 is perfect, so is the V6J but it's about half a powerfull GPU wise.

I think the W3J is also cheaper than the V6J too.

I don't suggest upgrading the CPU tho, i don't see how spending close to 300$ for a 150-300 boost in mhz...

So check that out.

Thanks,

MysticGolem

 

well i really liked the style of the v6j vs the plainer look of the w3 but i guess thats kinda dumb right?

i duno anymore now its between v6 and w3, but i wont be gaming that much, i have my 360 for that. il be taking this to college btw lol. i want power and an elegant design to go w/ it and the v6 just looks so sexy

 

If you arent into gaming much. The w3j is no comparison in style and contruction to the v6j.

 

If you go with the V6J, I wouldn't bother upgrading the processor from 1.66 to 2.0...It's honestly a huge waste of money, and you won't really notice much real world difference between the two at all. You're much better off buying it with the stock processor, and then upgrading the RAM and hard drive on your own if you're that concerned with having great performance. That way you'll keep your Asus warranty and still have a blazing fast laptop for pretty much any everyday application you can think of.

If you go with the W3J, I'd recommend doing the exact same thing...leave everything alone when you buy it, and then upgrade the hard drive and RAM on your own if you want.

Take our advice and leave the processors alone, you really won't notice much improvement, certainly not in relation to what you're paying and giving up to get it. Good luck, Whaever you end up getting, If It's an Asus, then you made the right choice

PS, you should really, really think about what your needs are though before you make a final decision. The W5F is small, but if you've never had a laptop before and you don't plan on heavy gaming...It will exceed your expectations in everyway possible. All three Asus models we're talking about here are cream of the crop, once you prioritize your wants and needs, it should be clear which model you need to go with. Good luck once again

 

hey thanks alot for all of ur input, it seriously helped alot

i probly wont be buying my laptop till late june so i still have time to consider everything.

once again thanks for everythng u guys are great (generic ass kissing) haha

 

You know if you like the w5f you might want to wait till july if you can asus will have a w7 a 13.3in with camera and dedicated graphics a nice little unit.

 

I didn't know you could wait, so I second that, If you can wait, wait until the last minute possible and then see what's available that suits your needs the best. The W7J looks to be a very popular model given It's size and dedicated graphics, the perfect one-two punch!!! You won't be disapointed with any of the Asus ensemble systems we've been discussing...good luck from there.

 

Perhaps this is a post for another thread, but it seemed there was substantial info and discussion about the W3j well before it became available. If the W7j is truly going to be available this summer, why does it seem there is so little official discussion about a release date and specs in NA? Perhaps I'm mistaken, or perhaps it was a lesson learned with the W3j and preorders? Just curious.

 

It has been discussed on many threads. but the w7 has been released in other parts of the world. So its only time. but its most likely this summer. either way you should wait for the last minute to buy a laptop. Becaus prices can only come down. and new models will come out.