Battlefield 3 or Modern warfare 3? *POLL*

Where Do You Stand In This Year’s FPS War

will you get Battlefield 3, modern warfare 3, both, or neither one??

 

None, Too busy playing red orchestra 2

Still im gonna buy BF3 but not gonna play it much, No idea about MW3 though at this moment in time

 

I would love to get into BF3 but EA still hasn't responded to my Crysis Warhead issue emails. If they don't fix that, I will never buy an EA product again.

I love MW though and will probably buy it.

 

This thread is gonna be so full of flaming in the end, but hopefully people will behave.

I already preordered Battlefield 3, so il vote that.

 

Battlefield 3 All The Way! :d

 

MW1
MW2
MW3
CoD WaW
CoD BO


all the same game. BF3 all the way.

 

MW games are too much run and gun, I hate how little the game has improved over the years..

I've never played a BF game, BF3 will be my first and I am looking forward to it immensely.

 

I just got BF2 lol, and Skyrim comes out like a week or 2 after BF3 so I'll definitely be getting that over these two.

 

BF3 over mw3 100 times over.

 

I'll probably go for MW3, as I'm kinda a run 'n gun kinda guy. I don't play that often, and CoD is easy to hop on and play.

But, I will definitely wait until it's on sale.

Agreed, lets not make this MW3 vs. BF3, there are way to many of those thread around.

 

I have been a hardcore COD fan since cod4 but I'm getting bored with the series. I WAS more excited about MW3 (even though I really like the battlefield series), but once I saw that nothing super new or interesting was being added to mw3, and seeing the jets/dogfights in bf3, I changed my mind. It seems like dice and sledgehammer are REALLY working tovmake bf3 an epic game. I wouldn't be suprised if it gets recognized as the best fps ever.

It just seems like the devs of bf3 are working hard with new ideas, and the devs of mw3 aren't working as hard and have run out of good new ideas.

Don't get me wrong. I believe both of these games are going to be great. I just feel like bf3 is going to take the #1 spot here. The close underdog always fights harder than the champion who's held the title for several years. Infinity ward got comfortable and complacent while dice set their goals to take that #1 spot.

 

Both. I play COD games for the "America, fk yeah" single player and I'll play BF3 for the multiplayer.

 

BF3, but I prolly won't play it until the Counter-Strike: GO PC beta is over.

 

You can't really compare the two. I believe BF3 will be the better game because it's like 5 years (or however many) in the making? Only reason CoD series got so boring is because they churn out a new one every year and it gets so stale.

 

BF3 all the way, although according to this American Pre-Order Chart, MW3 seems to be winning, though most of these pre-orders are from consoles.

 

Battlefield 3. Call of Duty has been dead to me since Modern Warfare 2.

 

^^^^^ This!

 

Time Line:

Call of Duty 4 < World at War < Modern Warfare 2 < Black Ops < MW3

How good is the game? (ignoring the fact that they should be getting better because each game marks a technological starting point for the next game)

??MW3?? < Black Ops < WaW < Modern Warfare 2 < Call of Duty 4

the trend isn't looking good. The games rate in nearly reverse chronological order for me. Given MW3's development issues (the lead producers were fired, most of the rest of the team quit shortly thereafter. literally.) i wouldn't be surprised if MW3 turns out worse than black ops.

 

Battlefield 3 ofc

COD is looking like Madden now, A new COD game every year with just a little new features added

If you have the money buy both

 

So looking forward to BF3.

I don't see the point in buying MW 2.5....err, MW3.

Just my 2¢.

 

Battlefield series is much more fun than the COD series.

BF3 all the way.

 

Neither, saving my moneyz for RO2...

 

Definitely BF3 it shall be epic

 

Both, I've played both series since their very first incarnations and I still consider both games on different planes, althought they are the same genre.
BF has been always immersive, gigantic, and geared toward squad based gameplay, long sessions which sometimes makes me ehxausted but satisfied even with negative ratio.

COD has been for me always the incarnation of Arcade FPS. Is less impegnative and deep compared to BF, its more fast and rapid, easily accessible for those pickup and play sessions without too much thinking.
Both styles grown up in me and I can play both without too much issues, either with realism oriented mechanic or arcadeish.

Just my 2 cents, plus I'll get both for $39 with preorder which is a bit more than a boxed version.

..plus Im a sucker for COD campaign and it's cinematic/movie style, the story always kept me going on, I didn't felt immersive enough BC2 story thought, I found it boring, short and disconnected compared to MW1 and 2.

 

Do you mean disatisfied or with a decreasing satisfaction level as time goes on?

I voted neither since that subgenre (military-style FPS) doesn't attract me.

 

It's more military themed than military style. Especially for call of duty. You're running around shooting faster than the fastest man on earth.

Call of duty could play exactly the same, but with space aliens and laser beams, and zombies. Oh yeah, they do that.

Battlefield has some degree of military style in the game in addition to the theme. Elements of focus include squad play, cover, suppressive fire, armored air and ground vehicles, choosing complementary classes among your squad (the best squads will include a mix of classes, potentially one of each of the 4 primary classes, to be able to handle any situation).

Call of duty is more about running and gunning, kill streaks, perk choice, leveling up to unlock the good weapons and perk bonuses, "going rambo", individual performance, KD ratio.

Just my 2 cents.

 

wanna hear a joke? MW3.

haha, jk jk about the joke.


but IMHO, BF3 ALL the way.

nuff said.

 

I plan on getting both, have both pre-ordered for $40 each. I wont get a COD game that treyarch will develop ever again though.

 

Both, actually, but with more expectations and enthusiasm for BF3 and none for MW3 (less chances of disappointment).

This poll should be based more on hype and popularity rather than actual game mechanics... they are a bit different (especially multi-player).

My vote for BF3.

 

This. Black Ops was absolutely awful.

 

BF3!!!

If the single player campaign of MW3 is as spectacular as the first two, then I'll probably buy it when it gets cheap.

 

too bad i cant vote on my own thread , i was going to vote for battlefield 3.

wait.......does it really make a differencet at this point?? lol

 

you should be able to vote on your own thread.

 

Probably both, but MW3 for PS3 from half.com or something after 5-6 months. I do expect to be playing BF3 a lot more though.

 

for me... mw3. i am boycotting origin, so i wont get bf3 until (please god) it hits steam. if i could get it on steam though i would chose it over mw3 in a heartbeat.

 

It's never going to happen.

 

I put both because I'll be playing BF3 for pc. I am quite good at COD though so I have to get MW3 for the PS3. Already got a great team for MW3, we are going to destroy the override ladder : D

 

Man, the polls were obvious from the start, there's like at least 3 threads talking about Battlefield 3 around here. Not to say it's overrated, but I didn't think a poll was completely necessary.

Anyways, I'm all for BF3, it's just the core concept of full-scale combat that overwhelms MW3.

 

Neither, personally.

 

It'll happen when SC2 gets on steam.

 

Neither, Gears of War 3 for xbox!

 

precisely, which means, get BF3 w/ origin, or get left in the dust 4 ever and ever!!!!!!

 

I agree its like kids playing with squirt guns in the back yard (cod) and actual war (bf3).

 

for sure bf3, have you seen the game on the PC?
it is amazing!!!!
mw3 is just more of the same.

 

Now that MW3 will have dedicated servers I will definitely be getting both.

 

Definitely getting BF3... Might also get MW3.

 

BF3 FTW!!!

Althought I must admit : MW3 MP does seem very fun! I'm going to purchase BF3 immediately, and then maybe MW3. But chances are I'll purchase both, but play BF3 the most.

 

I'm getting both. They're different styles of game, and both fun in their own way.

 

BF3>Barbie Fashion show Game,>MW3

 

Although Origin sucks and web site server browsing sucks I still am looking forward to BF3 way more than MW3.