Western Digital Passport External Hard Drive Review

by Vivek Gowri

The Passport is Western Digital's line of portable external hard drives, featuring a very sleek casing reminiscent of the Nintendo DS and WD's 2.5” 5400RPM SATA notebook hard disks. Due to the use of a lower powered notebook hard disk, the Passport can be powered by the USB port alone and does not require the use of an external power adapter, and thus makes a very nice portable storage solution.

Why Purchased

During Black Friday 2006, I purchased a Western Digital MyBook 250GB external hard drive to add some additional storage space for storing my music and videos, and also to make backups easier. One year and 500+ hours of video later, I had less than 8GB remaining from the original 250, so a new storage solution was necessary. When Black Friday 2007 arrived I figured it would be the time to get a new one. After reviewing the deals, two caught my eye: the 120GB WD Passport at Staples for $49.98 after a $30 MIR, and the 160GB version of the same at Best Buy for $69.99. I was going to both stores anyways, so I decided that I would decide which to buy when I was actually at the stores. At the end, I went with the 120GB one solely for the price difference, though in retrospect, it might have been better to get the 160GB for the extra disk space, since its going to take at least a month for Staples to give me my $30 back anyways.

(view large image)

Packaging, Design, and Features

(view large image)

• Dimensions (H/W/D): 0.59”(15.5mm)/5.1”(130mm)/3.1”(80mm)
• Weight: 0.23 lbs/3.68 ounces/104.55 grams
• USB cable (USB-A to mini-USB) length: 11”

The dimensions of the Passport really surprised me. It is not too much bigger than an average wallet, or even the first generation Zune audio player, and is thus easily pocketable. It does not add a noticeable load to a backpack full of textbooks and notebook accessories, due to the four ounce weight.

(view large image)

The packaging is very simple, just a cardboard box with a plastic holder for the Passport inside. There are only three things in the box: the drive itself, its USB cable, and a small instruction sheet. There is another SKU for the same drive that has a nicer box, with a clear plastic tube as the box. Its more flashy and high end, but at the end of the day, its the same product inside.

(view large image)

The enclosure is very sleek, with rounded edges and a glossy black finish, so it instantly reminds you of the black Nintendo DS lite that is an extremely popular handheld these days. Even the logo is in the same spot – though here it is a matte black rendering of the WD logo as opposed to an airbrushed DS symbol. The design is very minimalistic, with the aforementioned WD logo, a small rubberized flap that opens to reveal the mini-USB port, and a small blue LED ring (which looks like a miniaturized version of the LED ring in the MyBook) being the only details on the top side of the Passport. The underside is similarly minimalistic, with a matte black finish, four rubberized feet, and a small sticker containing the product information, such as the serial number, model number, and country of manufacture.

I've carried it with me for a week now, and it is already showing some scratches on the glossy casing, not to mention a ton of fingerprints, though those are easily wiped off. This could be a problem for people that are very conscious about fingerprints on their gadgets, but the look does match the new HP notebooks very well, with the very glossy black finish and tons of fingerprints being very similar in both.

This is, I must say, one of, if not the, best looking external hard drives I've ever seen. Its sleek almost to the point of being sexy. When was the last time you could say that about a hard drive? Western Digital also offers it in other colours, like a metallic red, metallic green, glossy white, and glossy pink finishes. I also remember seeing a metallic blue, but it isn't listed on the WD website.

The short USB cable could be a good thing or a bad thing, depending on how you look at it. It keeps the drive close to the system always, cuts down on cable clutter, and is better for traveling, but you can't connect it to a USB port thats farther away, like under a desk. I personally prefer the shorter cable, but I have a biased perspective on the matter, since both of my computers have their USB ports just below the monitor and cable length is thus never an issue for me.

Western Digital also includes their Sync synchronization software with the Passport. According to WD's documentation, Sync “lets you save your critical data, personalized computer settings, and all your personal files on a WD Passport drive. When you travel, you can use WD Sync to plug your WD Passport drive into any PC to access and edit your Microsoft Word documents and Excel spreadsheets, MP3, and even Internet Explorer favorites in a cybercafé, on a friend's laptop, or in a colleague's office. You can even send and receive e-mail securely from your WD Passport drive using WD Sync. After you're back from your travels, WD Sync synchronizes all your changes to your home or office computer keeping your files up to date.” It uses a 128 bit Advanced Encryption Standard to keep the data on the drive secure, providing 3.4*10^38 possible, distinct key numbers. I have not used Sync, because I prefer to manually transfer my movies and music on the Passport, but it seems like it could be a useful application for business users and those carrying sensitive data that use multiple computers.

Performance

The real world test – I took a file from my video collection (702MB video encoded in X.264 and saved in .mkv format) to use to test the file transfer speed of three devices: the WD Passport that is the subject of this review, the internal hard disk in my Asus W7S-A1B (Hitachi HTS541612J9SA00 – 120GB 5400RPM, SATA), and a SanDisk Cruzer micro 2GB, one of the most common flash drives out there.

Test file properties (view large image)

I copied the file to each disk and used a stop watch to time how long the transfer took. The numbers might be slightly off due to human error, but not by more than a tenth of a second. So here are the results:

• Internal HDD to Passport: 32.99 seconds
• Internal HDD to Flash drive: 95.37 seconds
• Passport to Internal HDD: 35.24 seconds
• Passport to Flash drive: 98.69 seconds
• Flash drive to Internal HDD: 34.34 seconds
• Flash drive to Passport: 37.50 seconds

What these figures seem to say is that the Passport is nearly as fast in transfer rates as the internal notebook hard drive, and much faster than a normal USB2 flash drive.

Benchmarks

In short, I was expecting the benchmarks to support my assertion, with the Passport being a bit slower than the internal drive. However, the HDTune benchmarks brought a very nice surprise, with the Passport actually having a higher average transfer rate than the Hitachi internal hard drive.

Internal hard drive (view large image)

WD Passport (view large image)

In general use, I really cannot tell the difference between the speed of the two drives, both seem equally fast to me.

Heat and Noise

The Passport runs pretty cool. Nothing really to report, other than the fact that it doesn't get hot at all. In terms of noise, it is very good as well – when transferring files, it makes some barely audible noise, but for the most part its completely silent.

Conclusion

The Western Digital Passport is a very portable external hard drive that boasts an elegant design and solid performance in addition to its range of colours and hard drive capacities. As a mobile storage solution, this is almost unbeatable for any type of user.

Pros:

• Very aesthetically pleasing enclosure
• Simple to set up and use
• Highly portable
• Solid disk performance
• Syncing software included

Cons:

• Fingerprints easily
• Accumulates scratches from regular use
• Higher capacity models are pricey

 

Thanks for the review Vivek. Seems like a nice no frills USB hard drive.

 

i've brought two so far and been really pleased with them. About the scratches and fingerprints, i got a cover with both of mine which helps protect but of cause still get some.

 

This version is the second generation of the Passport line. The 1st generation Passports were a little bit thicker, and made of a semi-glossy (what appeared to be) aluminum case with a blue rubberized bottom. I have had both, and definitely like the fact that WD slimmed them down. What I dont like however is how they resorted to using plastic instead, and moreover *glossy* plastic, therefore being much easier to scratch and get fingerprints on. The case that you get it with (standard if you buy it from Costco and a few other places) is great, and WD continues to have the nice rubber door that covers the ports. Having had both the 1st gen and 2nd gen they are still great products

(and nearly impossible to take apart unless you are fine with breaking it in some form or another)

 

I have the Seagate version of this (The FreeAgent Go 120Gb), and my dad has the predecessor to mine (a 100Gb portable external). They're very nice, as they add quite a bit of storage without weighing you down. I actually prefer them to desktop externals (I don't need a whole lot of storage space, and additional 120Gb is enough for me!)

What's nice about the seagates is that since they have a matte finish, they won't get fingerprints and scratches very easily (though the front and back ends of the FreeAgent can get scratches easily). However, the FreeAgent go seems to have a rather cheap and flimsy case, whereas my dad's older Seagate is all metal (but thicker and heavier as a result). Another good thing about the FreeAgents is that they too have syncing software (though I uninstalled it on mine).

Just my $.02 on the WD Passport's competition.

 

I prefer the larger but faster desktop external drives, as I don't carry them around with me. However, if I did, I agree with you on the FreeAgent Go drives.

 

Does USB2 limit a drive's speed?

Out of curiosity, I used HD tune to benchmark my 250GB MyBook (7200RPM, 3.5", PATA), and the graph is a perfectly flat one at 28.5MB/s.

 

Unfortunately, a FreeAgent is not exactly the cheapest external 2.5 around, in case you haven't noticed. Wish it were cheaper. I would take it over the WD anyway, but right now, CC's letting 250GB WD's go for $130! o_o Little tough to resist.

 

I have one, it seems pretty nice. I have a question though...how long is the life span of an external harddrive, typically?

I sort of want to use my external harddrive to store my music, which means that it will be constantly accessed and used when I'm playing music on my laptop (which I do quite frequently). Would constantly accessing it like this be bad for the life span of the drive? Or would this be safe to do. I normally think of using external drives as a place to backup files that I access infrequently, so for some reason I feel as if I'm not supposed to be accessing the drive all the time, heh.

 

The drive in an external USB HDD is the same as regular ones you find in your notebook or desktop. You will generally find 1.8" or 2.5" notebook drives in the smaller ones or 3.5" desktop sized drives in the larger ones. Hence, constantly accessing the drives is not an issue. I have several external drives (small and large) and these are being used much and often. The latest ones, I have had for about 2-4 years. No problem thus far.

 

I just measured my $10 (unbranded) USB enclosure, actually it is slightly smaller than WD passport at (H/W/D 13mm/120mm/75mm). Therefore size is nothing to be surprised of..

I think they should concentrate more on coming up with a better way to carry that cable. Usually I take my disk with the cable wrapped around it because I cant be bothered unplug it every time and then carry it separately.

Why cant these people design a retractable cable or something useful like that for a change instead of coming up with some stupid multicolored shiny casings

 

lol , yeah a retractable cable would be far better
My external hdd currently has a 120gb setagate momentus.2 in it , @ 5400rpm , and also i dont notice a drop in speed over time , the graph is straight , why is this?? the internal hdd always gets slower over time whereas usb ones dont... is it some sort of caching system? is that why.

 

HDD potential transfer speed is well in excess and oversaturates the interface's capability, even at the slowest internal sectors, so that results in the flat curve on HDTune. I.e. the HDD is faster and the USB can't keep up with the higher speed so what you're seeing in HDTune is the max transfer that your USB connection can deliver across all sectors.

When connected through IDE or SATA connections internally, the interface has more bandwidth than the HDD can deliver so that's why you see the decreasing curve across sectors - the HDD is the limiting factor in this instance, while the USB connection is the limiting factor on external USB2 connections.

 

I've got two 120GB Passports and loooove then!

 

Western Digital makes nice portable hard drives, I have the 160gb version of this

 

I own one - the boxing was different; mine came in a blister pack. But dude it's so very nice

P.S.: Sivaji?!?! Oh.God.NO!

 

So you all are hinting that its about time to upgrade my old 40GB passport? (bought at a time when my laptop only had a 20GB drive) I was checking out some of the specials at BB last week. Good stuff, but I really don't need to travel with that much data anymore. My current 160GB internal is only 1/3 full. Still I find myself strangely attacted to getting a new one.

 

I think there is a bug in this hard drive. Whenever I try to copy any .iso file from my PC to the Passport drive, it say the passport hd does not have enough space.

Did any of you experience this?

 

I always wondered the latest speeds of the external HDD's that doesn't require a separate power source...


PS. Nice Avatar. (But sorry, Go Kimi!)

 

I gave it a bit negative review:
http://forum.notebookreview.com/showthread.php?t=97810

 

I just bought the 120GB one today for 89.99 + taxes so it was like 101 @ staples! Damn and I had to drive to 3 different staples, because the first 2 where out of stock...@ the second store I was told there were 6 more at another location but when I got there only 1 was left! =) No MIR though...I could have got the 160GB for cheaper price if I lived in the US...

 

Have you tried changing the format of your hard drive from FAT to NTFS?

 

I just got the 250 GB version. Wonderful drive. And yes. I converted to NTFS from FAT. That's the first thing I did with the drive.