HP Omen 17 SKL/1070
When the BGA cutcorner is so big you need to fool the customer thinking that the laptop has a bigger heatsink
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Looks like one of those ricer cars that put on fake hood vents or exhaust.
At least Alienware does it better: http://forum.notebookreview.com/threads/funny-thing-i-found-on-the-15r3-2016-heatsink.797784/
Also gap big enough to put a penny inside
![]()
And then some...
![]()
In the process of foil taping up all the heatsink holes right now...
@Mr. Fox @Papusan @Johnksss@iBUYPOWER @ryzeki @hmscott @LunaP @TomJGX @Raidriar @Khenglish @Prema @Phoenix @Meaker@Sager @don_svetlio @pendragonfalls @PendragonInc @DackEW @Dackzy @woodzstack @Prostar Computer @iunlock @zergslayer69 @DeeX @Cass-Olé @Galm @triturbo @Ashtrix @D2 Ultima
-
-
reserved
@FastMover -
brb dying of laughter.
-
Illusions doesn't translate to performance in the real World, but what's hilarious is how many poor saps fall for it. -
LMAO Mr. Frank Azor's Marketing strategies definitely had some impact wow !! , Blatant fooling in broad-daylight. Next is what for the BGAverse ?? maybe silent gimping of the PCIe lanes on the NVMe SSDs etc..
Vasudev, TBoneSan, Papusan and 1 other person like this. -
Someone who has this model recently was asking if his 98 degree CPU was safe or not. I believe it was at stock BGA clocks too.
Don't these manufacturers actually do testing in their design phase? That's a rhetorical question.
It's pretty obvious the contempt they have for the people buying their trashy products.
And yeah.. it's a total ricer machine. Like have dual exhausts, only for 1 of them to be a dummy. -
Also it's ok for the CPU VRM not to have a thermal pad (this particular one), great quality control! /sVasudev, Papusan, TBoneSan and 1 other person like this. -
Shamefully poor engineering. They forgot the word "bad" in front of Omen, LOL.
I think the only reason hp still exists is because stupid is an epidemic among consumers, and equally sad to say that most gamers are not really an exception. How any gamer can respect them after what they did to VoodooPC is beyond me. I bet Rahul Sood can't forgive himself for selling his soul to those losers.triturbo, Papusan, TBoneSan and 1 other person like this. -
Average gamer with average BGA gaming system
TBoneSan, Mr. Fox, Papusan and 1 other person like this. -
Why... why don't people report on this stuff? I don't understand! The number of "good" reviews HP Omen has had since it came out; I keep seeing people recommending them and Acer Nitro series. WHY?
-
-
nvm
-
-
-
What's with the hate on BGA? It has its place. Maybe I want to bting around my laptop to school everyday without having to carry a 2 inch thick weight.
"GTX 1080 in a thinbook is fine" -Razer -
More and more trash out there
Are these hardware engineers ostriches? With their head down into the sand? Looks like someone is missing their head. Either ostriches with the head under the sand or Lack of
Thanks for sharing @Mobius 1 +rep.
Ashtrix, TBoneSan, D2 Ultima and 1 other person like this. -
I think we can all agree that BGA has a place. There is a special one, in fact.
An equally viable option...
Rage Set, Ashtrix, CaerCadarn and 2 others like this. -
Most of the people that buy them are unable to recognize trash, and they believe too much of what they see on the internet is true.Ashtrix, TBoneSan, Papusan and 1 other person like this. -
Spartan@HIDevolution Company Representative
-
All the hardcore power enthusiast has left the AW ship long time before it sailed out of the harbor... And the BGA passengers who wanted to stay on the ship have already started to swim back towards the harbor and the most hardcore BGA boys crawled below decks.
-
Then they put a mini m. 2 slot (ugh can't think of the size number on top of my head) but slot 3 is the mini me port. Why Why why?
Dell will ever fail to amaze us.
HP doesn't care about anything but their corporate accounts.
Definitely a budget bucket for that massive crowd. I'm glad @Mobius 1 can expose the real deal, because someone has to do it. That's why we do what we do... To call it out.
Sure, everything has its place, but "certain things" should not belong in "certain things."
Most people: "It must be better because the number is higher than a 6700K right?"
Intel / Companies: "Laughing all the way to the bank."
The comedy: These low binned cripped HQ's cost just as much as desktop chips.
Sad day.
::iunlock::Ashtrix, D2 Ultima, TBoneSan and 1 other person like this. -
Sent from my OnePlus 1 using a coconut -
Meaker@Sager Company Representative
Mr. Fox likes this. -
-
But yes I agree, this is just like the razer book pro. Just sad...
::iunlock::D2 Ultima likes this. -
Terrible doesn't even begin to describe it. I was going to post a small essay on BGA in the lost enthusiasm thread, but after I saw this, I'm not going to. BGA deserves all the $h!t it gets and then some. They'll NEVER do it right, so I wont bother as well. I just hope that when such turd fails on someone, (s)he doesn't mindlessly go and get another POS (it would fail outside warranty, just because that's the whole point) but instead do some reading. If that doesn't happen, well they deserve to be punished every 2 years + a month or two.
-
Anyone that believes Intel and NVIDIA and their puppet partners have our best interests at heart needs to pull their head out and pay attention. They absolutely do not. This hp turdbook literally is an omen... of what their dismal vision of the future for "high performance" notebooks looks like. With Dell and hp and Apple kissing their posteriors and bowing to their command, it will take nothing short of a merciless mutiny to turn the industry on its ear and cause them to fail miserably financially. This is our only hope for a brighter tomorrow. People that open their wallets for this digital feces are part of the problem. This is only true because their agenda doesn't make room for those of us that expect more. They want us all to own disposable trash and there is no way that can happen if both options continue to co-exist peacefully as they have for years. Therein lies the problem. They drew first blood. We need more real enthusiasts that are committed to do whatever it takes to cause their failure, even if that means abandoning the concept of high performance notebooks forever. If all of us committed to never pay more than $500 for any BGA turdbook and convince others to do the same, the battle would be short and the victory sweet. Unfortunately, there are not many willing to draw that line in the sand.
This is one of the reasons I am passionate about the Tornado F5. I understand some people want smaller and some actually need it. The Tornado F5 is a thorn in the flesh of BGA Nazis, because it is everything a 15-inch beast should be. It can't hold a candle to the P870DM3, but it doesn't need to. It utterly destroys everything in the same size class.Last edited: Feb 19, 2017 -
It's sad but the professional workforce is getting shoved with crap machines.
The Zbook are either fully BGA or half-turd with MXM quadros and BGA CPU.
Also to stay on topic @Mr. Fox
I have confirmed that HP didn't put the thermal pad on the CPU VRM, but the heatsink clearly has cutout to put pressure on a thermal pad (if one was there).
Gap is around 0.5mm I believe, not sure. I used K5 pro.
Idk what's wrong, I think HP is trying to sabotage the machine from the start so that the VRMs burn out under normal use.
Even with undervolting I don't think I will use the machine without some sort of cooling on those VRM array.
Fan itself is not able to disassemble in effort of making cleaning and re-lubing the bearing impossible for customers. The way that the two halves of the fan is secured together is by melted plastic studs.
That whole foil tape thing took me a good hour to complete.
steberg, triturbo, Mr. Fox and 1 other person like this. -
hmscott likes this.
-
This is what the evil corporate, money hungry infidels that worship money & greed are banking off of...well let alone the ignorant who don't know any better and pay up the storm for such machines. (In the case of those truly needing power and opting for a bga machine when they could buy a F5 15" or a 775 17" for much cheaper.)
As stated in my review,
"The major thing that I've noticed about all these machines is the tolerance of how much of a hit it can take in a storm under stress, along with the integrity of the systems to be able to stand on their own two feet. - I've just thought of an excellent analogy, one in which tells the story very thoroughly.
A fully socketed machine is a house built on a rock.
A hybrid machine is a house built on gravel.
A bga machine is a house built on sand.
When the storm comes (petal to the metal / when these machines are put to the test under high stress) with rain and the floods crash on in...the house built on the sand will wither away (bga) and at times so will the house built on gravel (hybrid), while the one built on the rock remains standing (socketed/lga). - Tech Verse M7:24-27
This is so true for these different form factors. It's been nice to be able to really put all of these to the test, because proof is in the pudding."
Solution: The better approach is to support such companies who still continue to offer LGA machines. Going the other way is a lost cause as the cancer runs deep. To be fair, bga has its place, but not at the price point of a superior LGA machine (if needing power). One would be a fool to lug around a tank of a monster if needing portability. It just doesn't' work well at all and it is annoying and not practical. Trust me, I've tried it. Not everyone needs a monster truck to run to the store to buy some things for dinner.
Where is this F7?Last edited: Feb 19, 2017Mr. Fox likes this. -
-
Thanks for the photos of the cooling system. Looks like quite an abortion.iunlock likes this. -
It has tickled a lot of nerves of the bga fan base lol.
::iunlock::Mr. Fox likes this. -
* I'm guessing, since there's no info on the backlight, but it's not WLED (can't cover such gamut), but not RGB LED either (with the IGZO substrate an RGB LED backlit panel could cover Rec.2020 (or the color space HDR standards are based on))
Last edited: Feb 20, 2017Ashtrix, t456, Mr. Fox and 1 other person like this. -
Last edited: Feb 20, 2017
-
Man I only wish that people weren't so stupid...
Ryzen clevo does sound promising @triturbo
I have enough money as it is to blow on a fully specced clevo with the eurocom 780w adapter, but I'll hold of if there's any glimpse of a Clevo with ryzen chipset.... -
Yeah. Put pressure on those who create the junk aka warn everybody against buying their overpriced BGA trash. This is the only viable way out from the dark. If the sale of their dumpster tumbles down 4-5%, it will affect them hard. Maybe they will change and offer something better. 4-5% seems low but I can tell you this will hurt them in their wallets.
-
-
Vasudev, TBoneSan, Ashtrix and 1 other person like this.
-
Look at where 8970m is standing, the GTX 780m used to lead. Also failing GTX 980ms didn't stop anyone from still buying them in masses. Anyway, the rotting BGAs is awesome, but unlikely to happen.
Mr. Fox likes this. -
http://www.3dmark.com/compare/3dm11/11067038/3dm11/7593998/3dm11/7630785
http://www.3dmark.com/compare/fs/7936496/fs/2457216/fs/2330540
The 980M fragility and weakness was inexcusable and symptomatic of using poor quality components and cutting corners to save a few bucks... really stupid things like leaving off half the MOSFETs the cards needed to last. I found one out of six to be durable, but with proper modding to address the areas where NVIDIA was incompetent they are almost bullet-proof.
Overall, it has been a sad state of affairs for notebook lovers for several years. We have multiple demonstrations of lameness from team red and intentional acts of evilness and betrayal from the Green Goblin.Last edited: Feb 20, 2017Ashtrix, TBoneSan, triturbo and 1 other person like this. -
Also to quote and not to forget how the Alienware transformed retarded into a castrated jokerbooktrash-milkingmachine for Dell & co.
Alienware History from 2006 - Present ( From King to Pauper ) and The Industries showing middle finger to consumers -
Dell had bought Alienware in 2006, it had the machines made by Clevo as a partner. which dates long back, Then further down the road we had many extraordinary machines - M15x, M17x, M17x R2 the SLI one - First gen i7 machines, Beautiful design and full customization options from website. Later we had the Sandy Bridge platform, M18x SLI 580M one and M17x R3 they all had beautiful same design principles and exemplary build quality unmatched performance and full MXM machines with precise heatsinks across all, This had continued upto the M17x R4 and M18x R2 with Ivy - Meanwhile the Desktop market also had amazing lineup with ALX chassis and Aurora, Area 51 machines which were top at that time - This is what Golden Age of Computers, Alienware, Liberty consumer choice was.
Starting from 2013 things went downhill in all, Dell announced going Private from Public in the same year 2013, Might wonder why does this have relationship ? - From a fellow member here who had a known contact at Alienware, So the reality was during the acquisition of Alienware in 2006 A deal was made, Dell will be funding the Alienware but slowly gain control over the Company and implement their own design standards, marketing strategies and principles. And immediately later 2013 - First blow was Win8 and It's B$ UEFI & the 14 Haswell machines came with HQ option - Intel BGA filth, started it was a shock to most of the people but by that time the dumbing of consumers took place, thanks to Facebook and kool-aid crap,
Also post M18x R2 time - Alienware Haswell Era with the removal of MgAlloy chassis to only middle frame, Lid being MgAlloy. Plastic Backplate with not so strong design, CPU and GPU fans with low CFM ratings, Battery removability gone need to remove the backplate, NVRAM BIOS (The Ultimate cancer infestation, CMOS reset wnt reset the BIOS need to use specific tricks, Secure Flash locking the sBIOS modding unlike the Ivy Bridge Platform - Gimped Fan tables, locked FAN RPMs in EC, No laser Etching personalized option, Removal of customization on website, AW18's motherboard hardpower cap vs M18x R2's no power cap, M18x R2 pulling from 600W using a dual power brick only match was Eurocom Panther 5 the X79 chipset machine which can run Xeons and Hexacore CPUs, She also got struck by the MXM dropping by Nvidia after Maxwell) M18x R2 started with 580M SLI to 680M SLI, 7970M CF, 780MSLI - Unfortunately 980M SLI didn't work properly when OCing the CPU and GPU causing some EC communication across the board and throttling, Dell could fix that but they didn't care. AW18 was delayed indefinitely (end of 2015) the time when Maxwell was announced maybe the Dell was restructuring the strategy and wonder why the Haswell had redesign ? Also Dell had killed the XPS performance machines to the kiddo crap now, Tried to come back with hybrid plastic combo for the Echo lineup and minimal metal....
Jaillienware now it is. 100% retarded POS garbage class (Whole brand not just NBs, Desktops are ultimate mess, A garbage fest (from Cass-Ole a fellow enthusiast, tried his best), Which is pumping this "Shiny" and brand misnomer who didn't knew what Alienware stood for and how they have been leading the crown on the path of Genocide of this BGA hell, Nice strategy they employed on forging an abomination called Metal chassis, with robust build and Ultra high performance JOKE to tune the crowd for their needs, to line their own deep pockets of insatiable hunger for cash without ethics & try to fix em up when things get to the Internet news channels ?! While keeping the gimping intact.
Since Dell departing from the PGA mobile CPUs to BGA hell Intel might have made all OEMs take the same direction, I highly suspect this is what happened with Dell dropping the socketed machines from 2014 & Intel could easily push the BGA abomination, MSI didn't even exist in this class at that time, Now here we are the BGA Genocide - All laptops shipping with that Garbage Win10 with it's UEFI, Privacy Invading, Eternal Beta cancer and BGA crap, Now MSI still offering stupid BGA CPUs while their nasty practices, famous in the MSI forum. No offense but the lack of choice and seeing consumer as just $$$$ machine is just nuts and not productive at all in both long and short run...
I'm so glad to see most of the Enthusiasts found new weapons that can annihilate this BGA / Gimpfest Cancer, disintegrating it at cellular level - Thanks to NBR's Enthusiast community for the supreme class reviews of really worthy contenders in the market who are in pursuit of performance on both software and hardware realms and actually think for "themselves", liberty.
Hope the Ryzen / F7 / Clevo / MSI follow the path they chose and not to crap their customers with this mainstream drama targeted by Extortionist Corporates.. -
Last edited: Feb 21, 2017
-
If you really need 4K... Buy an external screen
-
I am the one that asking about the 100C cpu in another thread. I had never had a high end gaming laptop before (always mid-range get the job done type stuff). One thing I noticed in this thread was the GPU not boosting. My GPU (1070) would boost to 1850-1911 all day and it never went past 82C. Most times staying around 72-77C while gaming at max settings. It was that cpu that was giving me problems. Anyways HP replaced that laptop with a 7700HQ. I will see how it handles heat and report back
hmscott likes this. -
Is there a non bga 15" laptop that is around an inch thick and not too heavy? After all the people in the Razer thread and my already dissapointment in myself for buying a Razer product I realized I did not look around enough and I should have just gotten a 15" that meets my needs. I am thinking about a Sager np8157 but I know this is still bga. I see Sager or clevo offer a non bga 15inch but it is 1.5" thick and 7.5 pounds. Any other brands that may have an option or is that the only model?
Mr. Fox likes this. -
EUROCOM Tornado F5 Mini-MonsterBook Review Thread
http://www.eurocom.com/ec/configure(2,384,0)ec -
Aside from that, is the only other one the NP9152? Even though there is probably no CPU upgrade path from the 7700k that will be able to go into these laptops I would like to go this route if possible. The NP9152 interests me a little bit more simply for the fact that it is a little bit thinner (yet almost a pound heavier?). The NP9152 however (atleast on HID) only allows me to go up to a 1070. If I were to buy a 1080, or wait for future better cards as a 1070 should be good enough for a while, would I be able to upgrade that in this model and add that card later? That 1.6 inches gets scarily close to my AW which I am really trying to avoid, but at the same time is .1in of a difference really a big deal for an extra pound? I am trying to sell my Blade and trying to decide between the NP8157 (yeah yeah I know BGA but I love the size of it) or the NP9152 or possibly the Tornado. I do not really want to spend the money on a 1080 now but I would like to know I could upgrade to it down the line if I really wanted to or future better cards.
Another funny thing in the BGA bucket...
Discussion in 'Sager and Clevo' started by Mobius 1, Feb 18, 2017.