Guys, I want to start a discussion about the Clevo P270WM and say a couple of words about its specs and features, how it fares against its cheaper counterparts P180EM and so on.
As most of you know, the P270HM features desktop CPU's on its platform and currently there are only the Sandy Bridge-E processors available for it. Since Ivy Bridge is just around the corner, coming out no later than after a few weeks, I hoped that the refreshed Ivy Bridge-E series would arrive to replace the 32nm Sandy CPU's. But after a little bit of research this morning I was heavily disappointed by Intel's roadmap for the "E-series" performance CPU's. They are supposed to hit the market in mid-2013!!!
>>>Link to read about it<<<
I planned to get one of these P270's this year, but it seems Intel's roadmap to failure convinced me not to do it. Thats full of win and here is why:
*Sandy E-series are all rated 130W TDP (battery life ftw! Second power brick FTW!)
*Sandy E-series are supposed to be "highest-end", but with 1.5 yrs old tech (prices for old tech are ftw!)
*Sandy E-series gets spanked by the mobile Ivy Bridge CPU's in single and dual-core, especially with OC (again, old tech FTW!)
*Sandy E-series has NO integrated graphics (goodbye, optimus! See you too, battery life!)
*Sandy E-series cannot be overclocked higher than the new Ivy CPU's (now where is the fun in that?)
*Sandy E-series doesent support PCI-Express 3.0 (talking about high-end...)
*Sandy E-series gets replaced by Ivy Bridge E-series in mid-2013, right when Haswell hits the market and then things get ugly - Haswell is going to spank them in everything but rendering and server operations. Way to spend some thousands on old tech!
Now, the Clevo P270WM gets handicapped because of these things in the following ways:
1.) Costs a good deal more, with older processor tech right out the box
2.) Can't utilise Optimus from its Nvidia 600 series cards, cause the CPU lacks integrated graphics
3.) Can't ulilise PCI-Express 3.0 cause of CPU supporting only 2.0
4.) Ain't getting better battery life until Ivy Bridge-E hits the market in 16 months
5.) Ain't being offered with AMD cards, no Crossfire for now, makes the user buy Nvidia's expensive stuff
6.) If you buy the P270WM now, then upgrading to Ivy E-series will NOT be a good option. By the time Ivy E-series hits the market, the Sandy E-series will be so old, that you will be lucky to get some 200$ for your old i7 3960X that costs 1200$ now. And who will want old tech? If somebody needs a replacement, they will look at Ivy Core i7's from the lower segment that are still more powerful than the old 32nm Sandy without PCI-Ex 3.0, with 130W TDP.
Things I like about the P270WM:
I.) Love its 3x HDD slots, possible for 4x with caddy
II.) Love that it has no glossy stuff (especially the bezel, nice to see its gloss-free)
III.) Love its 17.3" with 2xVGA slots, instead of the 18.4" P180HM that is hard to find a carrying bag for
IV.) Would love to have a desktop CPU in a laptop, sadly that aint happening. Not with old 32nm tech. Never.
V.) Would have loved a 32GB of ram in a laptop
VI.) Like its display hinge, a lot cleaner-looking than the other P series. Also like the subwoofer thats on the right side, instead of beneath it.
Well, I won't be buying a Clevo P270WM after all. Not with that price, not with all the old tech going on. And restricted to Nvidia... to make it worse, no hopes for Optimus. Might as well have made it with AMD cards only. Could've been cheaper.
So, I hope my little rant doesen't upset you guys, but I really needed to post this. I just don't understand - shouldn't Intel aim for releasing the High-End Extreme series of CPU's first and then on to the consumer series? Why do they release them 10 months AFTER and charge ridiculous high prices for that? I can't see the logic in that.
AMD needs to step up and do something....
-
-
The P180HM is a much better bang for the buck and the performance is just as good. BTW, I had no problem finding 3-4 good bags that fit the 18" P180HM.
BTW Ivy bridge is kind of pointless for power users........if you need igfx though look at the M18x Alienware laptop. -
How does the finish fare in your machine? Any complaints so far? -
If you want optimus with sli and Ivy Bridge just wait for the 17inch P370EM...
-
Considering IB was really meant for people who wanted integrated graphics, it's not a surprise that the IB processors are a fail for gamers.
-
Yeah, you got most of the weak spots right. One thing though, the 3960X won't drop to 200$ in a year from now, you can still sell it for 600-700$ easily.
Also, I'd blame Intel for not providing a special chipset with IGP+SLI/CF+Sandy-E. Such chipset would be a great choice for the P270WM.
PCI-E 3.0 is a gimmick anyway, so no biggie.
And of course, my main complain is why on Earth would anyone want to pay 1000$+ for the 3960X if there's no way to OC' it. Clevo should really focus on this part and provide a better cooling. They can do that, just mod the heatsink to add extra 50-70W of (load) heat transfer and everyone will be happy! -
Absolutely, Aikimox!
I found out about the Clevo P370EM just now, thanks to Prema
Looks like this 17" will be much like the P270WM, except with mobile CPU and Optimus and all the stuff I want in it.
Cant wait for pics from it!!! This might be just what I want, and hey - its coming in late summer/early fall! By that time, I will have the cash to buy it without selling my current config first and still have cash for all the upgrades I want.
Might even get it when (or IF) AMD launches 7990M (at all) and get extra 10% juice in performance. Just like I did with my current config, with the 6990m. -
Why would you need optimus on a DTR? The battery is not meant for battery life. It's basically a UPS. In terms of old tech, the i7-990x is still crazy fast. It will handle any games for probably a couple more years. SB-E will be much the same case.
As Aikimox said, PCI-E 3.0 is a complete waste. No single GPU card can max out 2.0's bandwidth and none probably will for a while.
Intel didn't build the SB-E chips for laptops. Plain and simple. This is why there is no IGP.
Lastly, AMD is phasing out the 6990m as the 7k series are right around the corner. Wait a little while longer and I'm sure they will offer X-fire 7970m's.
You may see this as a complete waste of money, but others may not.
Just my 2 cents. -
PC-Konsulten.se Company Representative
-
-
One other point to make on this one.
Do you really believe Haswell will be released mid-year 2013? When has Intel hit a date when AMD has not been pushing them? Why would Intel release the IVB-E chips and then turn around and release Haswell based chips within weeks?
My best guess is, unless AMD is working on some top secret CPU no one knows about, you'll see Haswell late Q4 '13 or slipping into 2014. Only time will tell. -
-
Since you are a notebook retailer, you must have seen it. Hope the NDA lifts soon and we can all see it!
I mean, come on. Desktop processors should come out BEFORE mobile ones do, right? And Extreme series CPU's should be the first ones to arrive, after them the trimmed down versions.
What we have here is Intel is offering their Extreme series long after the Sandy Bridge launch (around 10 months after the initial launch, not sure), now we have mobile Ivy Bridge coming in 2 weeks and the DESKTOP Ivy from the Extreme segment are coming in June-July 2013 at the earliest!
Right now, they offer 130W CPU's using 32nm for the server/enthusiast segment. I really dont get why. Maybe its (again) about selling the belated warehouse items they have left in-stock. Its always about money, customers go second.
P.S:Since you are a notebook retailer, you must have seen it. Hope the NDA lifts soon and we can all see it!
-
well u said it urself: SB MAINSTREAM cpus have IGP, whereas the EXTREME cpus (SB-E) dont have IGP. if you really think about it, it does make sense, since ppl buying the high-end line chips surely wouldnt bother with the integrated graphics
besides, SB-E maybe "old tech" as you put it, but theyre still the high-end chips, beating any other SB and (upcoming) IB cpus! So performance-wise, Intel does not promise too much
cheers
PS: 990X is gulftown btw, not SB-E -
SB is by no means old tech. Ivy Bridge is barely faster clock for clock. It was just a die shrink with 3d transistors. And like Jaybee said, SB-E will be the fastest desktop processor until IB-E hits next year.
I don't mean to sound like a troll here but Intel didn't design SB-E around Clevo's laptop. It's just not going to happen. All most all of their sales from desktops chips come from actual desktops. So they will cater to that market alone. -
Errr... You know there is a P270WM owner's lounge, right?
Intel always releases their desktop hex-cores near the next gen. This happened before, and it will happen again.
If you wanted one of these, battery life and power brick size should obviously not be a concern. Buy a W110ER if you actually expect to haul this around frequently.
It's not 1.5 years old, SNB-E was just released. Where...?
Why would you waste your money on one of these if you can only use 2 cores?
Again, shame on you for wanting to use this on battery.
You can't prove that until we've seen this laptop and had a chance to mess around with it. Anyway, if you can actually use 12 threads, 600Mhz difference won't matter.
So? If it did, what would you use it for? No mobile GPU on the market can max out what we already have, and very few desktop GPU's can come close.
So use them for rendering and server operations.
As I said, SNB-E isn't older tech, it's brand new.
Bringing up battery life again.
Remind me how it will improve anything again..?
Please stop.
Fail? 675m are cheap. As in, $300 each.
So don't buy a 3960X, buy a 3930K. Also, I was unaware that old CPU prices deteriorated so quickly. I see $300 core2quads all the time. Oh, and one year is not old.
P170EM can do 3 with caddy, if you really need RAID5. Though 4 HDD's in a 17 incher is nice...
Why are glossy screen bezels bad again..?
Like everyone pointed out, there will be a P370EM with dual GPU's and P150EM coloring. You should get it instaid.
You want a desktop CPU, here it is. And 32nm isn't old, ivy isn't even out yet.
P151HM1 and up (except for P180HM and x7200) can all support 32GB of ram.
Yes, the subwoofer is cool.
The prices are there because intel can get away with it, and 6-core CPUs take time to develope. Oh, and regarding the topic title, how does intel's roadmap have anything to do with the power of the P270WM?
Bottom line, I suggest you wait for the P370EM. It will give you your dual GPUs in a 17 inch chassis, 3 HDD's (with caddy), and Ivy Bridge. By the way, what do you want to do with this? -
).
And while I do understand that Intel wouldn't make a Sandy-E+Igp combo on a single die, the could at least make another chipset with an IGP integrated into a mobo (like they used to do) and offer the option for those who care about battery life. -
-
If I didn't know better I'd think you were calling the 270WM a total loss. I just bought one myself but I am fairly certain that unless its broken in some manner, it won't dissappoint. My last Sager/Clevo DTR ran for 7 years before failing and ran everything I threw at it during that time, only at the end did it start to hiccup as the MB failed (due to heating I think, partly my fault for not replacing the cooling mat I had with it for the first 6 years).
Waiting on a new one is great if you have the time, many may not. With the old one 10-6 I need a replacement in short order. I'd honestly leaned toward the 18.4" model, but the significantly smaller RAM limitation gave me pause as 3-4 years out it could prove to be a wall on running new games circa 2015 & on. The 180s were also of limited availability which meant I would essentially be buying a machine that was already phased out, thus obsolete 1 year earlier or more.
The price on the P9270 was also less than I expected, when I originally specced it out it came around 5300 on a site that had an early configurator up. When the time came the graphics card was different, and the overall price dropped by over $1000 from what I'd originally found speculated. This may be partly a function of what you are stating about newer tech coming out soon, but I highly doubt its a $4k doorstop I just purchased.
And frankly, if you are buying a DTR and concerned about batteries, you are buying the wrong machine. I never run mine on battery save just to grab info off it. The old one throttled back performance on battery by 50% - not what I consider a handicap because its not supposed to be a laptop, but a one piece desktop you can easily carry from place to place with greater ease than a tower & monitor, mouse & keyboard. Its meant to be run from the wall, not the battery. As others said, the battery is a UPS. -
Just to make a few things clear:
1)People buying such a CPU do care, or should care abouta n integrated GPU as one use the games not always. Mostly one use windows and it low need for gpu, and as such having a powerfull dedicated GPU that is always ON doesnt always make the best sense.
2)As long as there will be a monetary system money will ALWAYS, and I mean ALWAYS come first. Regardless of what ppl may think this will always come first. ANd its the greatest Brake that there can be for PROGRESS
If i were to tell that every disease is curable and that that can be done without spending a dime, probably you would get the better picture. All the pharmaceutical and medical industries exists only and only for profit.
This applies also in the electronics industry where things are specificaly desigend to brake so that ppl always buy new stuff, fact that is esspecially enforced by the fact that in the electronics industry new technology gets easily obsolete. This is done without the smallest regard for the total resources the earth posseses. -
Exactly, well said
-
People keep saying to "wait wait wait", the problem is there is always going to be something "better" around the corner. If your ready to buy a laptop now, then buy one. The new models in reality only give marginally better performance in reality. Many apps and day to day tasks will not run any better or any faster.
I picked up my P180hm.......pretty much has everything I needed, fast i7 SB cpu, dual Ati video cards, 3 HDD bays(4 if you swap the optical drive), a nice big 18" display and its futureproof in terms of upgradeability(CPU's,RAM,HD's,Video cards,wifi card all upgradeable). The only "downside" was the lack of a backlit keyboard, but the one it comes with I found is actually very nice(extremely sturdy with NO FLEX), and I ended up buying a wireless backlit Logitech keyboard and trackball for when I dock my P180hm to my projectoer and use it as a full hub media server off the 120" projector screen, or when I put it on my bed headboard at night and want to surf before passing out. It actually worked out much better this way I found anyway. I could have spend $1500 more for the Clevo 270 with a SMALLER screen, less efficient desktop cpu(that doesnt gain any performance benefits over the mobile i7 yet sucks down alot more power)but with the backlit keyboard. Not a worthwhile tradeoff at all, especially since I gain in reality no real world performance increase. So, I get a kick out of people holding off on new tech that is ALWAYS delayed by many weeks, months and even sometimes over a year or so. Not worth it at all. WHile you all are here talking about potential(and marginal) performance upgrades on vaporware, Im here ENJOYING the current and latest tech for all my apps and games. I mean, there have been countless threads on "IVY BRIDGE" BEFORE the P180hm came out the end of last summer.........and its still not out yet, lol. WHen it finally does come out, I can just imagine what new vaporware will be the new topic of discussion. -
custom90gt Doc Mod Super Moderator
-
I agree... I wish these companies that were in it "just for profit" would do something about cattle plague or small pox. Why do they keep stringing us along?
-
-
As for more USB ports, your aware that the xpress slot on the P180hm is available and you can add 2-3 more USB 3.0 slots without issue. RAID? Its already supported. What specific MAJOR new features do you think is going to be available that already isnt now?
-
Optimus.
Edit: 6-core processors as well.
Sent from my HTC Desire using Tapatalk -
-
-
Maybe in 5 years.
-
Or HP Elitebook 8560w.
-
I'm just wondering because you seem to throw away every argument for the new series... -
Thats why you probably didnt hear about it yet.
I tell you that me beeing a doctor.
But thtats just off topic.
On topic. I sure hope one could use the future octo core 20 mb cache cpus in p270wm. That is something that is going to exists not so soon in the mobile cpu line.
Here will be the great advantage of the p270wm. -
As for the gloss screen. Yep, I agree that the "reflections" for some can be annoying. I for one actually prefer a gloss screen though since it does help the "punch" factor in the display, and the gloss screens always seem to have better ANSI contrast.......not sure if it has to do with the gloss film or not, but they always seem have better vibrancy. As for the 120hz option, I agree this would be a nice option, especially if you had a video card system thats capable of punching out 120 fps vsync'd for games........just don't know of many video cards capable of doing this, especially for games at native resolution currently. -
-
The way I look at it, if I buy now at the end of cycle, that's theoretically almost a year sooner that I have to buy my next laptop. Why not stick with what I have for a couple more weeks and get the new stuff early on in its lifecycle? -
-
-
I agree with you that the stock M18x and P180 screens are fine, maybe more than fine...but not nearly as good as I'm used to. BTW, I used to own a M17xR2 with RGBLED (one of the best TN high gamut panels of its time) but it was still sub par to the HP 8740w. -
very soon indeed!!
-
bah, the "retina" display is still old LCD technology, with basically a slightly higher pixel count than 1080p. DOnt get me wrong, it does look really good, but its time to delve into technologies far more advanced with fewer drawbacks in the 4k pixel resolution range..........
......and to add, I still get a kick out of "High definition" 720p/1080p displays...........its really no real improvement over the old 240-480p crt displays from the 80's............why? People seem to forget that back in the 80's a typical average screen size in home was about 20-25" 4:3 sets with resolutions ranging from 240-480 lines. Now today, typical tv sets in 16:9 format in homes range from 40-60" and many people now emply pjs with much larger displays in the 100" range or greater.........so per square inch the actual pixel density really hasnt changed or improved much from the 80's in reality........ -
Haha, like they say in futurama "Computers may be 2x as fast as they were in 1979....". Yes, I totally agree, it's really a high time for a better screen tech, though personally, I'm waiting for holographics or screenless pcs. And their 1080p is a joke, I'd rather go back to 1200p panels.
-
if the come out with 4k displays, i want them to be able to make it so it can run at a quarter of the resolution for gaming purposes, by having each four physical pixels act as one pixel.
-
-
-
Anyone else know if the p270WM *is* the model which will be running QUAD GPUs in SLI?
-
There is no such model, that was a 1st of April joke, hehe. Such system doesn't and won't exist.
Quad GPU would require ~400W, which means together with a single 6-core CPU (locked at stock frequencies) the system would require 650-700W PSU. The battery would probably explode if you were to unplug the beast from the wall. -
Here I am perpetuating the joke! And I fell for it.
In any case, while it will bother some, that kind of PSU doesn't bother me for my needs. A "true" [DTR] in a laptop chassis is what I want. Oh well, who knows, by next year, something like this may be on its way. As you often post... :dreams. -
Disappointment: Intel fails the potential of Clevo P270WM...
Discussion in 'Sager and Clevo' started by b0b1man, Mar 27, 2012.