Hey im looking for new laptop and just learned about sager desktop performance laptops. Can preorder with new coffeelake 8700k not sure if good idea? Would love to have desktop performance on laptop and dont mind so much the extra weight and low battery life, but worried little about possible thermal issues and if im investing so much i want it to last. Thoughts? Are these reliable..?
Btw this is not for gaming/graphics so gpu will not be pushed, only cpu
-
We don't know yet. Just wait until the benchmarks.
-
Delidding isn't too big of an issue, as long as you are careful there is little to go wrong. But it depends weather you are willing to do that or not. If you wait a bit longer some of the system builders will sell you a system which has already been delidded and repasted. -
Arrrrbol likes this.
-
-
Thnks guysArrrrbol likes this. -
Might be worth asking @Mr. Fox about how his 7700k is doing. -
@Arrrrbol
There is an Asus notebook (Asus Rog Strixx GL 702ZC) which has desktop Ryzen, it runs very cool on stresstest. (high 80s C or something) and witcher 3 novigrad it stays at an impressive mid 70s degree, considering how flat the notebook is the temps are downright scary.
Mr.fox did this to his notebook:
He overclocked the CPU to 4.7ghz but it would downclock itself to 4.2ghz and still maintain really high temps (85-90c). The reason this is happening is NOT thermal throttling, mr.fox simply undervolted and unveramped the CPU to much that if it needs to work more it would downclock itself because it needs more power.
He made a new video with witcher 3, sadly only tutorial where you see the temps rising higher and higher in the tutorial where it doesn't take much performance (only around 20-30% CPU usage). I supsect another 85-90c 4.2ghz throttling in novigrad when playing the game. Maybe mr.fox will update on that later. In the end, only the stress guy made a video about how he got good temps, he claimed it runs at 4.2ghz stable but he didn't show the clocks ingame yet, so I'll won't say that it's fixable until I see stable clockspeed and low temps yet.
In the end, If you take a BGA CPU or LGA CPU in terms of gaming and normal usage like browsing, watching videos etc. it won't make any difference at all.Last edited by a moderator: Oct 26, 2017 -
-
Thanks for all that danishblunt. If 7700k had such high temps 85-90 even stock and modded i dont have such high hopes for 8700k. Coffee lake will probably run even hotter than 7700k. As i dont want to delid or mod my laptop and like a good number of years lifespan thinking now maybe best i just get something like a 7700hq msi. Thanks
-
If you don't mind the bulkyness, a MSI dominator might be your choice. In gaming I have around mid 60s on my 6700HQ (only put new tim, no mods or anything) (7700hq should be pretty much the same) and my graphicscard is also derping around the same. According to notebookcheck the GTX 1070 runs at 72c on stresstest furmark, so in gaming you can again expect around high 60s on max when opting for a 1070 based MSI, my GTX 1060 is derping around 50s on load in gaming, but I got solid tim on it. These temps are WITHOUT turning the cooling feature on, meaning the notebook reaches around 60-70c in total on a relatively quiet system, the noise the notebook makes is very good considering the hardware. My clevo which specs a stronger CPU and soon same GPU, is much hotter and way louder considering I even modded the heatsink, got liquid metal etc. it's downright a dissapointment.
Also yeah considering the new Clevo is the same Case, I don't really have high hopes for the 8700K being cool either, but you never know. Honestly most cooling solutions clevo made are terrible, not on Alienware 2015+ level terrible yet, but way below MSI's cooling solutions in their dominator series and Titan series. Until I don't see benchmarks and stuff, I won't say it's impossible tho, I'm honestly hoping for something neat, especially when looking at how good MSI managed to keep the 8700 (non k) version so cool in their MSI vortex G25, so maybe we are lucky and clevo finally managed to understand how important heatpipes, airflow, proper connection between die's and heatsink etc. are.
Last edited by a moderator: Oct 26, 2017 -
That guy really has no idea know what he is talking about and any "advice" given should be taken with a grain of salt. Every time he posts that kind of nonsense it exposes his lack of understanding. He has no idea how a properly tuned P870DM3 runs (mine technically now belongs to @Dr. AMK since he bought it and it is enroute to him now) and making assumptions about an anomaly that he sees in a YouTube video, for only a small point in time, where the CPU momentarily downclocks because it doesn't have enough load from the game to need full turbo truly highlights that lack of understanding and experience. The behavior he assumes to be a problem is totally normal and the 7700K runs full tilt for as long as it needs to in the P870DM3. (This is not the case for the MSI 16L13 because MSI created artificial limitations to performance, as do most notebook manufacturers.) With proper tuning and @Prema BIOS the P870DM3 lacks nothing in terms of CPU power or potential within the confines of a notebook's air cooling capacity.
All one has to do is compare the benchmarks posted by me and several others on HWBOT.org and Overclock.net to the desktops with the same CPU that are incapable of achieving equal or better results on air cooling or consumer-grade liquid cooled desktops with 7700K. There are no Core i7 BGA turdbook alternatives that can go as high and as far as 7700K, unless you get a really horribly binned and far below average sample of a 7700K to compete against a very rare and exceptionally well binned sample of a 7820HK.Last edited: Oct 26, 2017poprostujakub, Ashtrix, DreDre and 6 others like this. -
HP and Apple in my experience are by far the worst for cooling design. HP seem to either cheap out on heat pipes or ventilation, and Apple just make their heat sinks retardedly thin so they have almost no capacity to soak up heat.
poprostujakub, Ashtrix and Mr. Fox like this. -
-
-
Last edited: Mar 22, 2018poprostujakub, Ashtrix, DreDre and 2 others like this.
-
My Razer and my brothers Sager with an HQ CPU in it both run/ran hotter than my 16L13 does and my brother uses my old U3 cooling pad with his laptop where as I turn my fans on max...just saying. They may run warmer than one would like or prefer, but it is definitly 100% possibly to get them running at more than acceptable temps, and usually lower than most other notebooks with a little TLC to the machine. I don't know about Sager but I love my 16L13, if anything the GPU is the issue not the CPU.
Mr. Fox likes this. -
-
I'm sure you have no convinced people. Your words are way more believeable than your own videos and actual numbers displayed on your own videos and other LGA notebook users. -
can anyone else confirm this statement that most consumer laptops run as hot or hotter than 7700k laptop?
-
poprostujakub, Ashtrix, ole!!! and 4 others like this. -
Most 7700HQ notebooks are way thinner and have way worse cooling, which means that they can get really hot as well. For instance the razer blade reaches very high temps on a a 7700hq, which would be considered hotter than a 7700K based notebook, but when comparing a LGAbook to lets say an MSI dominator GT72vr, the 7700hq is around late low 70's c on stresstest while the clevo runs at 99c.
MSI 6700HQ MSI GT 72 Dominator Stresstest CPU max temp:79c:
Note, that the 6700K is the superior CPU and you can unvervolt, delid and mod the cooling so that it gets to acceptable/god temps, but in doing that you spent extra money for an LGA socket based system which you could have in BGA version with better and quieter cooling.
Here is an extra of the razer blade pro, which is around 88c on stresstest.
There are ntoebooks like the regular razer blade, macbook pro and XPS 15 9550 which have disastrous cooling and cause rather massive thermal throttling, so it reallly depends on the notebook itself as well as the hardware.
In the end you shouldn't take my, mr.fox or anyones word, just read what we write and do some research yourself to see what is reality, there are plenty sites out there showcasing benchmarks, stresstests, temps and reviews on youtube also showing the same information.Last edited by a moderator: Oct 26, 2017 -
When I say that the P870 and 16L13 are the only laptops worth owning I am serious about it. In the context of my expectations this is 100% accurate in every respect. Even so, they are far from perfect. Being the best laptop doesn't necessarily mean good. They have the greatest potential to be awesome, and part of that is they are not disposable soldered junk. Anyone that tells you a 7820HK or any other BGA CPU is the equivalent of a 7700K in terms of performance potential really doesn't have a clue what they are talking about and they are misleading others by presenting that kind of misinformation. Nothing offered in a BGA model is capable of meeting my expectations and it is physically impossible to use one of them in the manner I want to use it. They are incapable of doing it.
But, I will admit that if all a person is going to play games at stock clocks a crippled BGA turd CPU is more than adequate, if merely achieving adequate is the goal. It takes a pretty gullible person to believe that a BGA turd CPU running 4.0GHz at 80-90°C playing games versus a 7700K that runs 4.7GHz at generally equal or lower temps than that and runs every benchmark stable at 5.2GHz are functional equivalents.
Not being content with status quo is why I have finally decided to move back to desktops. I had 3 in my signature. Now there is one. There is one left because that one is a special project, a gift from a good friend, and the mod planned is a favor to people I want to help with a GPU upgrade. Also, because having a laptop is a nice thing to have. But, I am not giving any more money to any notebook manufacturer because all any of them ship is broken stuff that needs to be fixed before I can use it the way I want to use it, or not capable of being used in the manner I want to use it. Fixing things and making something pretty good into something great can be fun for a while, but over time it becomes pretty annoying because you're paying top dollar for something that requires your immediate attention because it was sold with defects.Last edited: Oct 26, 2017sweepersc2, jclausius, DreDre and 3 others like this. -
More powerful CPUs make more heat while doing more work
The tradeoffs in design to feed the cpu with the power, and handle the heat, are up to the individual buyer to weigh against the added cpu performance. The old cost/benefit analysis. If you don't see a valuable Benefit to you... all you will see is Costs.
Individual units from any manufacturer can fail in a QC sense from as little as a single badly torqued screw. Some Clevo resellers might not care as much as others when assembling, or testing, or you may experience a difference in customer service because they're not global scale corporate operators with more experience in returns and warranty but are more often small/medium businesses.
Advertising and branding also generates a sizeable fanboy army of viral marketers out there saying how "brand X is the best" and then confirmation bias flavours everything they say (*cough*Razer*cough*)
IMO if you want your stuff to work with minimum involvement don't buy a performance unit from a cut price reseller who dgaf. They *WILL* need more maintenance over their life because more is demanded from it. If you want a car that will survive on 3 year old oil and swamp gas, you buy a Camry or 90s Hyundai... not a Ferrari
I buy most of my Clevos second hand and they are in an average operating state. A "service", dedust, fixing heatsink and pad contact, Prema bios/vbios, and in the last year liquid metal, every Clevo I've owned can faaaaar outperform its rated specs and do so reliably. Would every single Clevo? I can't honestly say that. -
If i dont go with a high end desktop cpu laptop than i think i wil probably go with a low end 7700hq laptop like msi gl72 which goes for around 800 bucks. Just dont see worth spending around anywhere near 2k if im not getting desktop performance. I want to use laptop not for gaming but heavy special tasking work that will often push cpu to its limits. Gpu is not important for me and will barely be pushed. Not looking to delid/overclock my laptop and not wanting to get thermals over 80c if possible because i want to get many years out if it. Since my graphics card wont be at all pushed could i get good thermals with desktop cpu laptop? If yes P870 that u guys recommending looks discontinued so perhaps coffee lake right choice?Or i could save and get a 7700hq baseline laptop
ThanksLast edited: Oct 26, 2017 -
The truth will set you free, but you have to find the truth first. Otherwise, a person is doomed to believe the silly talking heads defending crippled BGA trashbooks.
http://www.overclock.net/f/21/benchmarking-software-and-discussion
https://www.3dmark.com/search
http://hwbot.org/
Proof: Check out the CPUs above and below the humble P870 with 7700K.
Last edited: Oct 27, 2017 -
Also my point is being that Clevo has inferior cooling compared to MSI for instance. I don't know if you had MSI notebooks (thicker ones) and compared those to same generation Clevos, once you did the same "service" on them, the temps are way better and the notebook is way less noisy. I noticed this over and over again, how the MSI notebooks and older AW notebooks were tempwise much better, even tho the older AW models were much louder.
We can both agree, that a repaste, reseat,lapping etc. will improve the cooling on all notebooks out there, but there are some notebooks like the clevos, where the temp to noise ratio is downright annoying.
@Scopus
Get the Asus Strixx GL702ZC, it has a RX580 and a desktop Ryzen 1700, it runs way cooler and is probably better suited for whatever you're planning on doing. -
Notebookcheck Asus Strixx GL702ZC Emissionspoprostujakub, Ashtrix, Dr. AMK and 2 others like this. -
poprostujakub likes this.
-
My guess is on stresstest due to non optimal power management the CPU goes down to 3.1ghz stable, much like mr.fox 7700k crysis 3 gameplay which goes down to 4.2ghz.
But hey, you can make up your story however you want, who cares about how the notebook clearly shows on stresstest temps that it literally cannot be a thermal throttle instead the lower clocks are caused by to low power management. Better go buy a thermal throttling 7700K right?
See those red numbers and how it says "Thermal throttle: Yes"?
As you can clearly see on the voltages on this stresstest, the power the CPU is getting is much lower than a desktop one, causing it to run at lower clocks on stresstest (note, it doesnt go under it's non turbo clock, meaning it doesn't even throttle but instead it doesn't boost to maximum potential).
Upp the voltage, maybe change of paste and you get full performance in a slim notebook with good temps compared to 99c 7700K furnacebook.
Really no issues here.
Honestly a 462mv undervolt and 3.1ghz on stresstest is impressive if anything.Last edited by a moderator: Oct 27, 2017 -
Your thermal throttling picture is from a Schenker XMG U706 (P771DM), that was released in 2015 with a i7-6700K, not the i7-7700K. You may wish to change it for one showing a i7-7700K in a P870 to tie in with your comments.
-
You do realise the gap at 1080p gaming is so great between the R7 1700 and the 7700K that an underclocked 7700K would still win in 90% of current games?
That AMDsus is GPU throttling to HALF SPEED and hiding its CPU temp across the shared heatpipe setup. It's terrible in games when the GPU is drawing its full 120W power! 3.2ghz is also its max 8-core turbo and FTLOG there is no 462mV undervolt that just highlights what you don't know about how power regulation works. Which is okay, noone can know everything, but don't pretend to know when you just don't.
Also don't be an anti-fanboy and lead someone astray by bagging an entire brand from one cherrypicked example just because your currently noisy CPU fan is triggering you as you type! -
how about 100c then? And yes, this is a P870 with a 7700K, and yes, it's even worse than the P751 with 6700K.
@bennyg
I am considering the performance, that's why I pointed out that desktop CPU's are superior performancewise, but my argument is, that it's not worth paying so much more money for the little bit more performace you're getting considering the thermal limits you will get really fast, also the much louder fans compared to other notebooks as well. Most things you use your notebook for, such as gaming, won't even stress your CPU out in any way. And those applications which do, will run like a furnace on a desktop CPU notebook. Instead getting a 7700HQ which runs cooler but also has less performance is probably way better, especially when you only want to game and have a 2k+ screen, which makes the CPU even more irrelevant. I just think that the thermals on a desktop CPU in a notebook are just to bad to be considered acceptable. Sure you can somewhat fix the temps, but the amounf of effort and money you would have to invest in it, is just not worth it, if somebody really cares that much about performance then a desktop will do way better.
Also, I was under the impression that VID stands for some default value in which the CPU needs to run stock speeds, when looking at the VID at 1.550V and the actual voltage is 1.082, which is an undervolt of 462. Correct me if I'm wrong.Last edited by a moderator: Oct 27, 2017 -
Louder? My 16L13 is quieter than any other gaming laptop I have seen or used, even when running on max fans. Where are you pulling all of this misinformation from? Most laptops now have smaller fans that have to spin a lot faster to try and push as much air, and in turn are louder than the bigger slower fans used in the slightly bigger laptops with desktop CPUs, what are you even talking about?
Rage Set, Donald@Paladin44, aaronne and 3 others like this. -
In the same review for the Asus ROG Strix GL702ZC, there is a comparison directly with the P870 in system noise.
In all the tests other than 'Load Average' the Asus is louder.
Load Maximum for the Asus is 57dB, whilst for the P870 it is only 52dB.
Link to the review again: Asus ROG Stric GL702ZCDonald@Paladin44, Stress Tech, Papusan and 2 others like this. -
Last edited: Oct 27, 2017poprostujakub, ole!!!, Donald@Paladin44 and 2 others like this. -
Stress Tech Notebook Evangelist
There is a lot of spoilt kids here that have to settle with a BGA laptop due to there budget size (no offence). This makes them sad, sometimes it makes them angry, and the odd times they feel that they have to knock down a desktop preforming laptop to make them feel better that they can have a BGA laptop...
Just read up bud! If you have an infinite budget, then follow what's in your heart.
I will like to leave a small prayer:
Oh Father God, my heart is filled from BGA fan boys, which is causing chaos and confusion. I feel as if I am drowning in my circumstances and my heart is filled with fear from NoteBookReview transgressors. I really need the performance, peace of fans, and advise that only You can give. Right now, I choose to rest in You. In Jesus name I pray, Amen.
And here is a small organ outro... a video of a P870KM1 (one version below the Coffee Lake laptop):
This Video (Full Fans on Clevo dash, 100% 3000RPM x3 Vardar FF5 fan mod cooler)
2560x1440
Nvidia Drivers: 387.92 Notebook
#1 1080 GPU: 52c max
#2 1080 GPU: 51c max
CPU 7700K 4.5Ghz: 60c max
*This video is rated mature*
Sorry about my Steam username, (unless you are a committed BGA lover). Please take a joke..almostoast, Ashtrix, jclausius and 5 others like this. -
Meaker@Sager Company Representative
VID is the voltage the CPU is requesting at any moment, what is actually delivered to it by the motherboard can of course be different due to things like vdroop.
Ashtrix, Donald@Paladin44, Papusan and 3 others like this. -
sweepersc2, poprostujakub, Ashtrix and 6 others like this. -
Just found out about hidevoution would happy to see they delid/undervolt cpus which might be interested in. Perhaps with 8600k or 7700k if can get good thermals. Hows the p775?
Spartan@HIDevolution, Donald@Paladin44, Papusan and 2 others like this. -
There are two good options for laptops with desktop CPUs. They are P870 and MSI 16L13 (aka HIDevolution 16L-G-1080 or Eurocom Tornado F5). You should pass on anything else or you will certainly regret it. @Rage Set (former owner) can speak to this and so can @Georgel (current owner).Last edited: Oct 27, 2017Ashtrix, Rage Set, Donald@Paladin44 and 4 others like this. -
Last edited: Oct 27, 2017Ashtrix, Donald@Paladin44, Stress Tech and 3 others like this.
-
Comparing apples to oranges and somehow an inferior product becomes superior by cherry-picking nonsense...sounds like WH press briefings LOL
poprostujakub, Ashtrix, bennyg and 2 others like this. -
Edit; looks like they do delidhmm this might be the one. If go with this need decide between 6700k n 7700k. Not sure How well this model handles?
Its only 100 dollars more for 7700k but wanna keep thermals low.
Also this not being major brand laptop little worried if something on it breaks in couple years will they have replacement parts and such..
thoughts?Last edited: Oct 27, 2017Donald@Paladin44, Stress Tech, Papusan and 1 other person like this. -
Also note that the EVOC machines come with @Prema BIOS, which is a HUGE benefit in spite of my partiality to Brother @Prema. I've had the pleasure and honor of working directly with him on testing firmware mods on several machines and I can tell you he pours his heart and soul into making the firmware the best it can be. Between the two of us, multiple hundreds of hours are invested in each product. Nothing gets slammed out in a rush and nothing gets released for PremaMod Partner Shops until it is worthy of PremaMod branding.
Check the photos in the opening post here for the mods (and which mods HIDevolution is doing): [SOLD] Mr. Fox's Crazy Wicked EUROCOM Tornado F5 / EVOC 16L-G-1080
Besides the 15 inch screen, the cooling requires more effort because the machine is smaller. Before making a final decision, reach out to @Donald@HIDevolution and @Eurocom Support to see what kind of custom builds they can do for the P870 with a single 1070 or 1080. If you already have your own drives and memory, they can do a build that suits your needs. You can get the vapor chamber with a single 1070 or 1080 and the temps will be crazy good since it is designed to cool two GPUs.
6700K and 7700K are very similar. Where the similarities fade and the 7700K shines is overclocking the CPU and memory. 7700K goes higher on both counts with greater stability and lower CPU voltage. Running something ordinary like 4.7GHz or less, and 3000 or less on memory speed, six of one versus a half-dozen of the other. I have had two three 6700K and three 7700K. Both need to be delidded to run cool, as did the 4790K. I actually saw no meaningful difference in temps between the two. So, take comments that one runs hotter than the other with the understanding that might have something to do with user error or drawing a short straw in the silicon lottery.
Most of my notebooks have been 18 or 17 inch screens. I had the Tornado F5 and the P750ZM with 15 inch screens and before I moved up to 17 and 18-inch monsterbooks an old 15-inch ibuypower-branded Compal HEL-80 gaming laptop back in the Core2 Duo and WindowsXP days. I definitely prefer the larger screens and heavier machines. The 15 inch is absolutely fine using it on your lap because it is close enough to your face to not matter. When you put it on a desk or table and sit in a chair, the 15 inch screen is not nearly as nice to use as 17 inch. If you plan to frequently connect it to a monitor (which defeats one of the benefits of having a laptop) and use it on your lap when away from the desk, then don't give it much thought... wasted calories thinking about that. The biggest advantage to a bigger machine is cooling will be better (due to more space for it) on the larger machine if it was designed with basic intelligence. In terms of cooling, nothing anywhere in a high end notebook is better than the P870 after delid and selecting the ideal thickness of thermal pads and a few other minor tweaks.
Hope this helps.
Here's this, too... in case you want to look at it... [SOLD] Mr. Fox's Amazing HIDevoluton EVOC P870DM3Last edited: Oct 28, 2017Ashtrix, DreDre, Donald@Paladin44 and 4 others like this. -
Thanks so much for all the helpful.info bro
clears much up and think since u say similar temps better go with 7700k with mods. will try get in contact with them see what i can do. Cheers
ole!!!, sicily428, Donald@Paladin44 and 3 others like this. -
Yes, no reason to select 6700K if you have the ability to choose 7700K. Both are good, but the 7700K is the clear and undisputed winner if you want to achieve better overclocking of the CPU and memory. Since the release of 7700K I have replaced every 6700K with 7700K because it is better enough to warrant the cost. The talking heads that say otherwise don't know what they are talking about, or they are not doing the right testing to differentiate them. And, I'd venture a guess that the vast majority of them have never owned and tested both CPUs in the same machine... just blabbering sheeple regurgitating what they heard someone else say in a YouTube video or read in the video comments, or read somewhere in a forum post... or using that as an excuse because they do not want to spend more on the better CPU (or they are content and don't want/need more).
Last edited: Oct 27, 2017Ashtrix, DreDre, Donald@Paladin44 and 2 others like this. -
so yesterday I uploaded a little (24min, 3,6GB, 8hrs upload with no fibre)video of PUBG running on my Tornado F5.
I'm really scarce, only 17th with 2kills for this run.
All graphics settings on "High" but Distance view on "Ultra", 1920x1080, driver desktop 388.10,
Ambient 21°c (70F)
6700k@4,3Ghz 71°c (160F)
Fan not maxed out (2 step low in MSI sw)
Gtx 1080@0,875v 74°c (165F)
Cheers and have a nice play
^_^Ashtrix, Scopus, Stress Tech and 2 others like this. -
@Mr. Fox any experience with the n950? Love to know how compares with f5 -
On Tornado F5:
delidded cpu from factory (EUROCOM),
repasted by me cpu with conductonaut liquid metal,
gpu (bad) repasted by me with phobya nanogrease and grizzly thermal pads,
bottom cover modded by Mr.Fox err Evoc..Ashtrix, Papusan, Mr. Fox and 1 other person like this.
Sager desktop cpu laptop reliability?
Discussion in 'Sager and Clevo' started by Scopus, Oct 26, 2017.