I had never these bugs in Windows like you. After a crash the system reboot without uv.
My m15 R1 has still warranty, too. You can everytime easy remove the PCH-Heatsink. Full description how to apply the heatsink in my link. It's easy, fast and safe, but in the end it's your device and your choice.
Haven't you seen it? 3,0mm. all dimensions are in the link. 3,0mm fits only for the PCH. On the PCIe SSDs fit max. a 2,0mm plate (+ thermal pad).
I can't it say exactly, because i had with my first heatsink huge core-temp-differences. Before repaste and after repast with kyronaut again. The temps were much better, but still huge core-temp-differences. (look in the repaste-link). I contacted the support with my HWinfo logs and got a new heatsink. This time i did the repast with lm, because for better passive cooling. I often use the m15 on battery and with better passive cooling the fans stay off and you've better battery life.
-
-
illuMinniti Notebook Evangelist
-
-
illuMinniti Notebook Evangelist
-
Well, AW15/17 users have observed PCH related throttling at 100C, rather than at 70C.
I am not aware of any relationship between PCH temp and noise levels. Seems to be purely based on CPU and GPU temps.
Longer lifespan might be a valid rationale in general, although in this case it's not clear to what extent lifespan of a PCH running at 70C is of any concern. -
illuMinniti Notebook Evangelist
The PCH is small, but that 70C is sitting right next to the RAM and HSF -
In addition, I guess there is some risk of the heatsink coming off and short-circuiting the laptop (or alternatively the heatsink may need to be attached permanently, which doesn't seem ideal). -
illuMinniti Notebook Evangelist
-
I wonder if it's not necessary, why so many other manufacturers use a PCH cooler on the same HM370 Chipset like in the m15/ m17? Often notbooks with less power than the m15. Some examples:
Aorus 15
Aorus X7 DT v8
ASUS Zephyrus S GX701
Gigabyte Aero 15 X9
Gigabyte Aero 17
Lenovo Y530
Lenovo Y540 (2019)
Lenovo Y740
Razer Blade 15
Razer Blade 17 Pro
BTW, with a PCH-Mod reach more points in CB R20
-
Your CB20 results are kind of lower bound of what I'd expect you to get on your i9-8950HK regardless of the mod. I get 3k on the i7-8750h.
Edit: perhaps your i9 stresses the PCH more, motivating the mod accordingly.Last edited: Oct 21, 2019 -
illuMinniti Notebook Evangelist
-
I've two devices. The AW17 R5 with i9-8950HK and GTX 1080 and the m15 R1 with i7-8750H and GTX 1060 (more for mobile things).
In CB R20 i reached 3.600 points with the i9-8950HK (R5). Simply limited by the powerlimit (PL1 100w/ PL2 110w). Not sure, but i think it's the highest score what i've seen in the R5 lounge. The m15 with the 8750H (PL1 75w/ PL2 90) is not bad. 3.113 point for the small device is ok.
etern4l likes this. -
Yep, a great 8750 score, however, AFAIR @CptXabaras got over the 3K hurdle with his LMed 8750 too (without a PCH mod). I'm assuming you LMed too given the extent of the overall modding effort. -
I did this score with normal thermal paste (kryonaut). 1:30 (time of the benchmark) to cool one chip is not a big challenge. Later I changed the heatsink and repasted it with LM, but only for the battery life. With LM I did't one benchmark.
etern4l likes this. -
-
illuMinniti Notebook Evangelist
-
I spent a lot of time in testing different mods, materials and heatsinks (with R4 and R5) and in almost all cases i used thermal glue, because you can it at any time easy remove without problems. Don't use UHU high temperature silicone glue! It sticks too strong.
One of many examples:
Testing various heatsinks and materials on PCH (copper vs. aluminum)
After the testing I swichted back to the aluminum heatsink. It's few degrees better. I've absolutely no problems to remove the old copper heatsink.
Same with my heatsink-mod testing. I tested over 5 heatsinks, every time on the same heatsink and I didn't have any problems to remove the mod or the old thermal glue. The old glue is a bit like rubber. -Full Story-, -Full Story2-
After the testing my heatsink looks still normal without damages or scratches or anything. That's why I'm curious about what you saw on google.
illuMinniti and etern4l like this. -
illuMinniti Notebook Evangelist
https://hardforum.com/threads/any-way-to-remove-thermal-adhesive.1229108/
https://www.overclock.net/forum/63-other-cooling-discussions/1337045-removing-thermal-adhesive.html
https://www.overclock.net/forum/63-...emove-heat-sinks-bonded-thermal-adhesive.html
https://www.overclock.net/forum/6-i...en-thermal-adhesive-north-bridge-chipset.html
I am not accusing your method of being false, I am just asking you what you bought and how you remove it because I have no experience with it and you have lots of experience with it. I tried to Google before wasting your time, but Google just resulted in lots of other inexperienced people saying "put it in the freezer" or "take a razer blade to it" lol. Both of which, I will not be doing.
Also, I did some tests, and they are basic tests because at the end of the day lower is better and I am not competing. I attached some 1.5mm copper heatsinks to both my 970 Evo 1TB and 512GB Toshiba from my m15. These are my Results.
2 Cinebench runs back to back
CPUs
89, 80, 89, 81, 85, 81
PCH
64
970 Evo
56, 80
Toshiba
44
GPU
58
3 Cinebench runs back to back
CPUs
89, 78, 89, 80, 84, 79
PCH
55
970 evo
40, 48
Toshiba
35
GPU
56
Link to images of the SSD's for anyone that cares : https://imgur.com/a/aERkNDU
Basically tl;dr - simply ading a heatsink to both SSD, resulted in temperature drops across the ENTIRE laptop. That is why cooling the PCH is important. Also, I didn't add a heatsink to the PCH yet. That is the PCH while still bare.
Note: The Samsung SSD would actually hit high 80s during gaming, these aren't min/max results, these are just results of doing some quick Cinebench. Nonetheless, heatsinks vs no heatsinks results in better temps and it is worth doing.
@Sk0b0ld if you have time, could you show me on the US amazon website what kind of thermal adhesive you would buy? Apparently the brand you use just doesn't exist here. And I definitely want something removable or nothing at all. Considering hot glue as a option since the temps that can withstand should be very safe pick.Last edited: Oct 22, 2019 -
Def recommend some additional SSD cooling mechanism though, because... well, it cools down the SSDs and thus prevents thermal throttling -
edit, actually you don't have these problems in the m15, because the SSD-heatsink screwed in in the mobo (attachment points). More important is the correct thickness of the pads.
An example with an AW17 R5: HWinfo-Log. The PCH from this guy reached over 90°C in a 15 minutes ingame-log. CPU-, GPU- even SSD-temperatures looks fine but don't forget, your system is only as fast as the weakest part in the system.Last edited: Oct 22, 2019illuMinniti likes this. -
SSD heatsink is also much easier to attach, in fact there is a Dell part that fits right in.
With the PCH mod, you keep referring back to the familiar AW17 R5 analogy, but evidently the PCH in the m15 doesn't run as hot. Is it the same chip model/variant? The one in the m15 R1 is Intel HM370 (Cannon Lake-H), however, not sure which of the several variants:
https://www.intel.com/content/www/u...s-chipset-on-package-pch-datasheet-vol-1.html
If there is any info regarding thermal throttling of that PCH, I missed it. Max operating temperature is 110C.
I'm not claiming the mod def confers no measurable benefits, I am more looking for strong evidence that it does. So far, I have your single benchmark results (encouraging, to be fair) with no pre-mod control benchmark.
The mod is a bit cumbersome (compared to a repaste), so would be best to have sensible rationale before doing the work, and taking the small risk of semi-permanently gluing a heatsink to the PCBLast edited: Oct 22, 2019 -
illuMinniti Notebook Evangelist
Also, I appreciate the tips on logging info. I just wanted to do it quick though since nothing had to be proved, your guide and info is more than enough proof for anyone. Maybe if I am feeling bored I will do a before/after of my system + PCH temps. I would be very surprised if it didn't give results that showed even -1 to -2C like the SSDs. At least I have the Cinebench score to notice if that changes as well.
Something cool to see would be m15 keyboard temps before/after the PCH mod since it is nearly in the center of the keyboard. Supposedly the m15 has a extremely hot keyboard, I never use it while gaming so I am not sure. I'm sure having 20-30C less from the PCH under the keyboard will give some results too.
And thanks a lot for the thermal adhesive recommendation. I am going to bond some random things tomorrow and see how it works out and if it feels safe to remove I will do the PCH mod. -
Jumping in the PCH discussion
I did a similar mod at the same time I repasted it. I did it for a previous 13R3, and it was much harder with that laptop. In the 13R3 the PCH was actually having problems. I've never had any problem with the m15r1, but it so easy, the space is there, the PCH is just sitting looking at you,
I just put a small raspberry pi heatsink, and it works perfectly. No need for kapton tape or anything else, probably the included adhesive is pretty bad thermally, but it is good enough for me.
It drives the PCH temps down by 5-10C. I've noticed than using a bluetooth xbox gamepad will drive the temps of the PCH from the standard 65C to around 75C. With the heatsink it never goes over 67C or so.
Also, after using a thermal camera on the motherboard (powered on without the cover), I noticed that the hottest part is by far the memory. I have the Kingston Hyper-X Impact 2666 CAS15, that seems to not include a thermal sensor, but I think it was around 75-80 doing nothing. I added some extra thick thermal pads so now the memory is dissipating heat to the bottom cover.
Probably these mods are completely useless, but what's the point of getting an Alienware? if I would like an "out-of-the-factory" experience I would go for a MacBookilluMinniti and DrewN like this. -
Spartan@HIDevolution Company Representative
-
Out of interest though: what thickness pads did you use in the RAM, and how did you affix them? -
Last edited: Oct 23, 2019illuMinniti likes this. -
Flying Endeavor Notebook Consultant
Alright, I just recieved an E-mail from DELL and they have agreed to send in a technician to inspect and possibly repair my unit by having a full on motherboard replacement. Thank goodness for the premium warranty. However, this would surely get rid of the Thermal Grizzly Conductonaut application that HIDevoution performed on my unit..
What kind of thermal compound do the DELL Tech Reps use as default...
etern4l likes this. -
How careful does the tech need to be to disassemble a computer with LM?Flying Endeavor and etern4l like this. -
The replacement motherboard/heatsink will come with factory-applied toothpaste. You can try asking the tech for a repaste or do it yourself, it's really trivial in case of non-LM.Flying Endeavor likes this. -
-
Flying Endeavor Notebook Consultant
-
etern4l likes this.
-
illuMinniti Notebook Evangelist
-
Flying Endeavor Notebook Consultant
Okay, I just ordered both Thermaly Grizzly Conductonaut as well as IC Diamond. Hopefully the DELL Tech REP would be able to apply or assist me in applying any of these two instead of the toothpaste that DELL has standard.. I am hoping IC Diamond would at least be able to control my laptop's thermal issues and last quite sometime but I would have Conductonaut on hand just in case I get lucky with the Technician that would come in..
-
Flying Endeavor likes this.
-
illuMinniti Notebook Evangelist
And like redmop said, be safe with it. When I went to do my first ever LM repaste on my 15R3, there was a air bubble right at the top. LM squirted out about 2 feet and luckily missed my laptop motherboard. Make sure to first dab some on a napkin away from the laptop. It left a stain too on my mousepad lolPapusan and Flying Endeavor like this. -
Flying Endeavor Notebook Consultant
I am not really confident with doing anything to the internals of my devices, yet alone applying LM. There is always the IC Diamond but of course LM is WAY better and would last longer. Originally, I wanted to go the entire time this laptop would be with me, around 4-5 years without needing a repaste.
Sigh.. I could always send it back to them since I purchased their shipping service, but my local bureau of customs would have a field day especially when they see how much this laptop costs. Oh wells... the problems of my nation xDc69k likes this. -
Anyway, the good thing is that the PBC underneath has lots of clean flat space, making the mod easier. OrI
Flying Endeavor likes this. -
I resolve to do my outstanding Phobya repaste this weekend so might as well try putting some pads on the PCH and RAM. -
Edit: looking at earlier posts and links the PCH is 23x23mm and heatsink should be 3mm max.
I ordered 3mm Gelid pads for the RAM, just need to find a Pi heatsinkLast edited: Oct 24, 2019 -
Flying Endeavor Notebook Consultant
-
I repastet over 20 Alienware (for german AW forum) devices with this technique and all devices have still low temps. My R5 and m15 i repastet on the same way. I think it's one of the safest method to use LM in a notebook.c69k, illuMinniti and Flying Endeavor like this. -
-
MH370 is the model, not a variant.
This is not necessarily a thermal limit issue. The m15 PCH usually runs around 70C although some people report it going to 80Cs under some scenarios. If it was thermally throttled it would be stuck around the highest reported temp (85C?) all the time.
Alienware took a bunch of really weird decisions with the m15 R2 (or they used another PCH variant which requires extra cooling). This could well be one of them. We don't know because we don't have enough concrete evidence on the benefits of additional PCH cooling in the m15. -
illuMinniti Notebook Evangelist
-
etern4l likes this.
-
illuMinniti Notebook Evangelist
Edit: ran two back-to-back FF15 benchmarks and PCH hit a max of 81C. That is only about 10min of intensive gaming benchmarking though. Whether or not there is improvement to the PCH temp after SSD mod, idk because my initial test was cheap, but I do know after hours of gaming my PCH has hit around the 90s. I just don't like to keep HWInfo running while I game because it keeps the external HDDs awake and spinning.Last edited: Oct 24, 2019 -
I bought a thermal adhesive tape, a bunch of 20x20x1.5mm copper shims. I should be able to use one or two and add a pad on top for a gentle case contact.
All the Raspberry heatsinks I saw were too high, or have too small base.c69k likes this.
*OFFICIAL* Alienware m15 Owner's Lounge
Discussion in '2015+ Alienware 13 / 15 / 17' started by ssj92, Oct 25, 2018.