I don't think anyone is trying to tell you what will make you happy; they're just trying to tell you what they believe you're entitled to - a computer of like kind and value. Obviously, you're allowed to have your own interpretation of "like kind and value", but the interpretation that most people take (including Mr. Frank) is that the HP/Compaq claimants are entitled to a computer equivalent to that of their existing computer (if their existing computer wasn't defective). We'll find out in a month or so as to what the Judge's interpretation of "like kind and value" is.
-
-
-
-
-
DV9000Owner . Thanks for taking my prior post seriously and providing a suggestion. I find all the jokes humorous but wish a few more folks would take the Proposed Order review a bit more seriously. From my perspective, there are a few items there that, if not corrected could cause major issues. There are a few others with percentages that I cant see why theyre there at all. Anyway .
-
This is now and always has been a negotiation between the two principal party's the "Class" vs Nvidia. Just because Mr. Frank has proposed a settlement doesn't as yet mean a thing. On Friday we "The Class" will get to read Nvidia's and Milburgs Response to Mr. Frank's entry to the case.
I am willing to bet they will try to napalm every single thing we "The class"
and Mr. Frank allege is wrong with the administration of the settlement.
Further they will move for complete dismissal of the entire matter
by arguing they have complied with the terms set forth in the settlement.
JMO -
-
I know there are some small potential loopholes in the proposed definition of "similar kind" but I think NVIDIA would have a tough time finding me a replacement laptop with a dual core CPU, 17" display, 1680x1050 resolution and no WIFI. I think your biggest point might be that not everyone wants a 17" model. I think the likelihood of NVIDIA replacing all notebooks with a 17" model are slim, due to the higher price of 17" models; but those people with a 14" laptop might end up with a 15.6" model. -
I have no preconceived or naive notions that things will not change. That said, one would have to be an idiot to see possible glaring holes in the base document and not point them out, consider clarification, or offer a possible solution. Example above. "If", for whatever reason, item (b) stayed as published, people with 14" notebooks could receive 15" models. Not so good.
JMO -
-
Dv9000owner…. I think you are correct, but given the level of resistance that Nvidia has displayed I wouldn’t be surprised by any action they may take. (i.e. pull WiFi cards, or custom order without). Just seems to me it would be better to have discrepancies (even small ones) squared away or in your hip pocket than go ….“Oh No”… who would have thought they’d do that!
Also, I don’t know about you, but I don’t respond well to pompous lectures.
Of course…not implying you. -
No offense at all taken there Mr. Wayne!! I think your jokes are timely and hilarious. I think I even sent you a rep or two for the funnies. I have to wonder though . about your sanity.
-
-
I understand... bum deals.... but please don't start calling me Uncle Dave.
-
How about Aunt Davette ? or NOT.
-
Shuuut Up..... I can't stop laughing.
-
-
I had seen someone on the engadget site saying we should be happy with what we are getting and the fact that depreciation "sucks"
It would be impossible to figure out what my laptop was worth (if working back in 09 when it died) But I was wondering what it would be worth now so I went to ebay's site and did a little research.
For the last 90 day period a working DV9000 is selling at a average price of $535 ( I know stupid right)
and
A new in box CQ56-115DX is selling at a average of $260 -
I received a notice. That was the day I created this thread on NBR.
I'm glad I did. The storm has been impressive.
-
-
I did receive a notice but I bought directly from shopping.hp.com.
Earlier I also received a notice for DRAM antitrust settlement for a 2001 purchase directly from crucial.com.... -
Did anybody notice they changed the tablet/netbook model?
Looks like just a bigger HD, still has Windows 7 starter, still far from matching our original in power and functions. :-( -
Nvidia's Faulty GPU Settlement Being Challenged
Looks like Tom's Hardware picked up the story. -
I'm wondering if maybe the nvidiasettlement.com site has a typo. I can't find a mention of the Asus EEE T101MT-EU37-BK anywhere. I can only find the eu17 and eu27 models.
-
-
savage25rcracer Notebook Enthusiast
i hope this does not change anything in the court doc. because they changed it feb/28/2011 last day for declarationsAttached Files:
-
-
-
-
Straight from the horse's mouth in July 2008:
-
-
-
nice catch on the EU37. even i had not noticed that i was looking at a different model. was this changed recently or has this been a typo from the start? as far as i can tell there IS no eu37...just a 17 and a 27...
wth nvidia? -
I think this is what your asking -
-
Now Milberg and NVIDA are making up computer models.
It looks like there are 4 models of the t101mt, EU (Starter) BU (Home Premium) and the 17 (1024MB) and 27 (2048MB) and they may or may not have bluetooth. -
I sent my Presario F500 in fedex monday and haven't heard anything if they got it yet. has anyone heard anything back or got a replacement yet from sending theirs in? I'm all excited and hoping to get it soon but knowing the way things go it could be months= eternity when in a hurry.
-
For example, 12", 15", and 17" screens are not similar kinds. Anyone can tell the difference even for non-technical types.
Tablets and netbooks are not similar kinds(however this could be confusing to people with little technical knowledge and don't own one of the two.)
Quad-core, dual-core, and single-core are not similar kinds.(again, could be confusing to some.)
On the other hand, Value is extremely subjective. It's especially difficult to tell the current market value(even without depreciation) of the old models.
Also, you may be willing to pay $500 for a feature while I may not consider the same feature worth $500. It's practically impossible to give an absolute, objective value for an older laptop.
Therefore, I think it would be fair enough to give a 12" for 12", 15" for 15", 17" for 17", dual-core for dual-core, and a tablet for a tablet. More than that would be too much to ask for...and not realistic.
Just my 0.02... -
According to the web site, you should expect to wait for 6-8 weeks before getting the replacement...
I already got the upgrade components (P340 CPU and 8GB ddr3 sodimm)...
But I am prepared to wait for a good 2 months... -
Also a google search linked to your message here. -
-
I found some 27 series T101MTs that only have 1024MB ram but seems the 27 has a larger HD. I think only the EU17 was sold in the US. The others with Home Premium, larger HD, and bluetooth sold in Europe and Asia. -
Although not a major leap, this appears to be a small improvement over the EU37 model. No matter how you slice it, there's nothing to be glad about. The Asus netbook is not a satisfactory replacement for a tx tablet and it does not comply with the settlement provisions. -
-
-
-
-
Did anybody out there put in a replacement claim even though their computer is still working? How long have you had it and has it been repaired before?
I'm just curious because mine worked ok for 3 years and two months before it crapped out.
Thanks. -
Sheesh!
ASUS motherboard box transforms into PC case | ZDNet
Don't tell Milberg! -
Yeah, they'd be on the phone in an instant: "Hey, 'ya got a cardboard laptop, by chance?" -
nVidia Class Action Fairness Hearing is Tomorrow - Almost time to make a claim!
Discussion in 'HP' started by Mr. Fox, Dec 19, 2010.