Dell may want throttle the GPU because they might be using a 180 watt power supply ..
-
-
Meaker@Sager Company Representative
180w is fine unless you overclock.
-
So if we want to game with the new aliewares, we have to hook them up to a desktop amplifier? what in the hell is the point of that? why wouldn't i just go buy a desktop rig? so now if i want to game at say the airport, or anywhere for that matter, such as in my basement on my tv, I not only have to bring my laptop, charger, hdmi, but now a DESKTOP AMPLIFIER with its proprietary cord, and its power cord? What ridiculous joke of mobile gaming design is this? Who the hell decided this would be a good idea for these larger laptops?
Well, Alienware. You're not getting anymore of my money. Between the BS i went through with my last purchase, and now this, It's safe to say I'm no longer a customer.Last edited: Jan 6, 2015 -
When the GA was introduced with the AW 13, I thought it was a cute idea. Buying a small notebook with portability the main goal in mind but having an option to hook up and play games when not on travel. Now, buying a big laptop only to have it hook up to a GA just doesn't make any sense.
eats7 likes this. -
The idea of GA is excellent. More upgrade paths are great. Where Alienware is going wrong, intentional or not, is making powerful systems and GA support mutually exclusive and the only upgrade path. It's so goofy.
Hopefully they get punished where it hurts, in the wallet. It looks like that going to be necessary for them to see that can't walk all over their customers and upping their game is people want.
I'll add to that. It's been almost 6 months and no sign of a 9xx series GPU. It's pretty obvious that the AW brand had a change in direction at the last minute. Look at the lack of decisiveness in them communicating what's around the corner. Sketchy at best.
It's not that hard to slap a some 9 series GPU's in their recently refreshed range.Last edited: Jan 6, 2015 -
Am I the only one who noticed the GPU on the AW 15 video? It shows a GTX 980M...
You can see it at 2:01
( Alienware 15: Up Close | Dell UK)kamlesh likes this. -
So three GPU options now known: the GTX 965m, the R9 m295x, and the GTX 980m. The i7-4710HQ is indeed the i7 option.
Of course, this could be shared with the 17 R2 video that will inevitably come and ruin this all, but I have doubts that would be true. -
-
It should come with a 980m. Dam you AW. I would have been all over this new gen had things been different. Anyway, hurry up and come to market, the least you can do is give us a dump of your VBIOS :laugh:
papusan likes this. -
lol a soldered on 980m. never thought i'd see that.
-
nightingale Notebook Evangelist
-
-
I really have no idea. They've probably locked down the BIOS so much that OCing without the GA won't be a thing and 180w will be ample.
I hate being so negative about all this but it really does stink. Let me balance it out...umm "it looks goods" and it's light enough with carbon fibre so my delicate little arms can carry it.
-
bumbo2 and Robbo99999 like this.
-
On the question of OC'ing, I am very curious how they will handle that on the AW 15/17 (and if there's an 18). I've been used to them locking the BIOS on and off for different chips for so long, it doesn't bother me as much. My M17x-R2 is with stock BIOS locked, while M14x's gpu is not, while one of M11x had OC options while the others didn't.
People are panning the G/A, which I understand is being naturally associated with the BGA, but as an idea it has more than a little merit. If we were continuing to see non-BGA systems, and with the G/A option on top, I think people would be thinking of it as much more positive. Just imagine if we had the inevitable slide to BGA and no G/A option.... -
The GA is way too overpriced imo, $300/£200 for an empty plastic box??? At the very least they should had added like 4 small wheels on it, so I can easily pull it around like a mini trolley.
-
Exactly my point here: http://forum.notebookreview.com/alienware/768731-alienware-15-hype-leaked-video-4.html#post9883479 -
The TDP is all relative though because 780M/580M/680M/980M share the same TDP but vary a lot with actual heat output. Id say a 580M runs much hotter than a 980M for exampleMr. Fox likes this. -
@Cloud: The 980M will reach well over 91W when overclocked, and people are going to be trying to overclock these Alienware's.
Overclocking is now going to be inhibited by the low-watt PSU's. There is no longer an SLI system, meaning there will only be small PSU's. Alienware has changed so much.Mr. Fox likes this. -
-
Exactly. Im not sure about why there is a difference in heat from two different GPUs tested on the same machine when they share the same thermal specifications.
Unless TDP is Max and a 780M runs much closer to that max while 980M in average runs considerably lower.
All I know is that it made no sense saying a 980M runs as hot as 780M (both 100W) when one is based on a 145W GPU (with 128 cores less) while the other based on 195W GPU. So there is something very fishy about the TDP info going around for mobile GPUs -
NVIDIA has not (unless something concrete surfaced recently) provided any official documentation on 980M TDP.
I don't have thermal issues with either GPU. 980M runs cooler than 780M, but I have never had overheating problems with 780M, even with max overclock. What is interesting is that my max stable 780M overclock is about equal to 980M stock, LOL. If svl7, Prema and Johnksss can help me crack the 980M power throttling issues it will be amazing. If not, I'll have to buy a Clevo so I can use them.TBoneSan likes this. -
-
It's like saying a game is free, but making it nearly impossible to play without upgrading to a premium account (less features, etc.).Mr. Fox, eats7, maxheap and 1 other person like this. -
Guys, I'm seeing a lot of trash talk on the GA unit; barring the launch issues with drivers etc. and a slightly high price ($150-200 would have been better, but you're only buying it once... so what the heck) I think it's a fantastic piece of hardware and something that has been missing for years for people like me who were bound to desktop computers. Up until now, external desktop GPU enclosures have been limited by PCI-E lane constraints and clunky software issues. I now have the ability (almost out of box) to get awesome gaming performance at home along with being able to take a fairly powerful computer on the road with me. The need to own both a powerful desktop and laptop has been eliminated.
I purchased the Alienware 13 and, excluding the somewhat lack luster processor which I have been closely monitoring but have not maxed out yet, I can not be more happy with the results so far. At home, my gaming performance is great. I have a GTX 970 in the GA and am maxing out all my games at 2560x1440 resolution (BF4, COD, Diablo, etc). On the road I get excellent productivity and reasonable gaming performance. Is it the highest level of performance? No. Is it more than acceptable? Yes. BF4 specifically plays much better than I anticipated since I always figured it to be a processor heavy game. The point is, I'm getting the best of both worlds and this is just the first iteration from Alienware! It can only improve as long as the hardware doesn't get dumped.
Over the past 4-5 years, within my desktop, I have had some version of an intel i5 processor. Each time I upgraded, I had a suspicion that I didn't really need to do it and wasn't utilizing the CPU nearly as much as I thought. Eventually I caved in and did some research and found this to be 100% true. As most people know in the gaming world, the GPU tends to be the primary source of bottlenecks unless you're using some extremely high end and expensive hardware.
Excluding certain models that allow upgrade-able components within a laptop, and even then there's a harsh ceiling to what you can upgrade to, you haven't had this ability before. Your laptop would age very quickly and you would feel the need to buy a new one. Like cars, laptops (and definitely gaming laptops) do not hold value well at all so reselling to minimize new costs wasn't very feasible. You would endlessly be dumping money into these systems looking for that faster fix that would bring you to "desktop replacement" status. You now have that faster fix in the form of the GA unit. I'm getting near full performance out of my GPU when compared to a similar unit in a friend's i5 4690 based desktop (GTX 970 G1 vs regular gigabyte).
Further more, as new GPU's come out, I will have the ability to upgrade to them as well. Beyond that, as new Alienware laptops come out, I'll still be able to upgrade that hardware even further! You're used to buying new laptops anyway right? I have no where near the same level of constraints as I did in the past from GPU performance, and I don't feel like I'll have the itch to buy a new laptop anytime soon. For the first time, I feel like I have found a true desktop replacement. I can game at home at full performance, and game on the road at a reasonable level. I'm scratching my head as to why there's a lot of haters that don't see it that way? I for one do not want to buy a new laptop every year, this gives me that safety blanket. I would have loved a little faster of a processor for piece of mind, or at least a quad core, but from the tests I've been running the past 2 weeks... I have no reason to really be searching for that. The fact that I should only need to buy this GA once is the huge selling point here, however, if Alienware changes the proprietary connector or something to make it incompatible with future laptops... that'll be really screwed up on their part.
Call me crazy if you don't see it this way, but I find my craziness valid. -
You actualy make some very valid points.
-
Fair enough for AW to offer a small and slim range with soldered components that can then be a best when you get back home - certainly why not. Just doing this to highend flagship products that should be able to work autonomously is a horrendous idea. -
Glad you like it, but I think you aren't running very taxing games if you can't observe bottle-necking. I assure you the potential is there with this pairing of CPU+GPU. If you can decrease graphic quality settings without a commensurate change in fps, you have bottle-necking. I have observed it already, and that with a circa 2009 game with max settings. Granted, it's not efficient code, and I am right on the edge of it bottle-necking most of the time, but there is no question that the processor will not maximize the GPU usage. You see a gain with an external GPU only because it can do certain operations more quickly that don't involve the processor, or minimally so. More CPU-bound games will not see as great an increase with the G/A and external GPU.
TBoneSan likes this. -
Im all for the GA, I actually wish they made a retrofit kit for my current 17 to work with it.
If they could get something to go through the unused DMC port that would be amazing! -
MSI is claiming graphics amplifier is limited to pci-e 4x speeds btw, I hope this will be either validated or proven otherwise soon, if this is true, AW is robbing people atm.
-
Mr. Fox likes this.
-
Robbo99999 Notebook Prophet
Trash talk about the GA is mainly based around the fact that they chose a ridiculously slow dual core low voltage CPU for the AW13, which in no way is enough to fill the boots of a desktop card! I think it's an OK idea - the whole GA thing, but they should have put an i7 47W CPU in that A13 I think - their current combination of CPU is a major oversight, a poor teaming of components, which is only ever gonna become more pronounced if A13 GA users ever decide to upgrade their GPU in the GA to an even faster model a few years down the line. It effectively makes the A13 + GA combination unupgradeable due to such a slow CPU, which was supposed to be the whole point of the GA to begin with!
Mr. Fox, Ashtrix, maxheap and 1 other person like this. -
There is a big misunderstanding here:
Alienware 17 AND 15 will have the following GPU options:
GTX 965M, 970M, 980M and R9 M295X.
Why they would use R9 M295X is beyond me. Unless AMD have improved the thermals somehow
2015 Alienware 15 and 17 are 20 percent thinner | Digital Trends -
Some people don't care about CPU performance. Case in point is AMD fanboys. AMD have a following of loyal customers that are content with lousy CPU performance. If you are an overclocking/benching enthusiast, this matters every bit as much as a beast GPU, maybe even more in some cases. For those that don't care if they have an awesome CPU, BGA doesn't matter unless a repair is needed and then you get a taste of the disposable/non-serviceable hardware poison. For those that don't care about having a great CPU, AMD offers socketed solutions and insane clock speeds that are amusing to look at in spite of their lackluster performance.
As far as why they would offer an R9 M295X, maybe they are trying to offer (a) low budget alternative to those that plan to be tethered to the eGPU and don't need any discrete graphics performance, or (b) something to keep the red fanboys happy. Basically, something for everyone except for the real high performance enthusiasts. We are now the abandoned stepchildren that don't matter to them.Cloudfire, Ashtrix, TBoneSan and 1 other person like this. -
I see an Alienware 15 in my future with a GTX980M.
-
I love the new keyboard on the AW 17 R2. They added more macro keys.
-
Robbo99999 Notebook Prophet
-
Yupp 980m finally seems to be confirmed, question is should i return my laptop for an AW 15 with 980m
-
The M295x is a 125W card. It's going to be a problem if you get this, especially with a 150W/180W PSU, lol.
The 980M does make the AW 15 a very attractive option.Robbo99999 likes this. -
Official alienware 15 and alienware 17-r2 pages are now reachable
NEW Alienware 15 Gaming Laptop | Dell
Alienware 17 Notebook | DellRobbo99999 likes this. -
-
Robbo99999 Notebook Prophet
-
I love how the 980M is only $150 upgrade to the M295x, LOL.
Worth. Every. Penny. -
Its 7 pounds though
still superior cooling and quality construction of AW makes 15 an attractive option over p35x and 650sg imho
-
Whoa! the 17 has 4 m.2 slots.... turbo speed!
THese are looking better and better to me! -
How does the 980M handle 4k? I won't purchase that screen if it's going to be like 20 FPS on ultra.
-
Robbo99999 Notebook Prophet
-
I suppose they expect those with the 4k screen to have the graphics amplifier, lol.
I'll probably just grab 1080p. Good ol' 1080p has yet to fail me. -
What are the possibilities of 120hz display being implemented after few weeks or months?Becoz if you remember when the 800m series gpu launched at first the 120hz display where not compatible with alienware 17 but then later on they were so was just wondering if i should wait to actually see or its 100% confirm that its not gonna happen ?
When are the new Alienwares with Maxwell coming?
Discussion in 'Alienware' started by Cloudfire, Sep 29, 2014.