UPDATED - The Mobile Graphics Card Info Page - Most GPU Qs answered

which graphics card for laptop is better for pro gaming
a) 512MB ATI Mobility Radeon HD 4570 (this is in Dell Studio 15)
b) 512MB Nvidia Geforce 9600M GS (in Croma;s Entertainment Series Laptop)

 

9600m GS by far.

 

I'm wondering how these two compare. I've read/watched reviews and they say the 9400m is good for low-med settings of games. For the ATI 3450 they say it isn't very good for games at all. so, if I were to take one against the other which would win?

 

the 9400m looks to be a slightly better than the HD3450.

http://www.notebookcheck.net/Comparison-of-Grafic-Cards.130.0.html

 

Thing is, the Radeon has it's own memory that isn't sapped from the RAM.

Also, NotebookCheck is notorious for not too scientific testing, if memory serves. Only good as a general reference point.

 

The HD3470 is in position 10 from the bottom with a score of 114

The 9200m gets a score of 139

http://www.videocardbenchmark.net/video_lookup.php?cpu=GeForce+9400M

 

The 9400m has it's own dedicated memory. It's ddr3.

 

which graphics card for laptop is better for pro gaming like playing games such as Crysis:Warhead, Assassins Creed, Race Driver:Grid, etc
a) 256MB ATI Mobility Radeon HD 4570 (this is in Dell Studio 15)
b) 256MB ATI Mobility Radeon HD 3650 (this is in Dell Studio 17)

 

Check this out
http://forum.notebookreview.com/showthread.php?t=302231

 

It is nerly impossible to find a review comparing these two video cards. I did some Googleing and it seems, that these two cards perform almot the same. Do not expect good Crysis gameplay, because they are not very fast. these are not video cards meant for serious gaming - they score 3100-3500 in 3DMark 06.

 

Neither of them are all that great, but on comparison level the 3650 is better than the 4570.
Both should be capable of medium-ish gameplay.

 

which graphics card for laptop is better for pro gaming like playing games such as Crysis:Warhead, Assassins Creed, Race Driver:Grid, etc
a) 256MB ATI Mobility Radeon HD 4570 (this is in Dell Studio 15)
b) 256MB ATI Mobility Radeon HD 3650 (this is in Dell Studio 17)

 

Dude, enough crossposting.
This is the third topic of yours I just read and they all have almost the same question.

 

check this link
http://www.notebookcheck.net/Mobile-Graphics-Cards-Benchmark-List.844.0.html

3650 is at 65th rank and 4570 is at 60th rank
whats the confusion
Which is better card for playing heavy games at medium settings
you just do research on this again

 

4570 has a 64 bit bus, leaving it well, very weak. Go for the 3650 or better if you can.

 

sorry bro, I apologize, plz forgive me
I'm new out here thats y I got confuse and post same question many times
I'm just trying to sort out my confusion, didnt mean to annoy anyone

 

In bench marking test 3650 is beating 4570
and you guys r saying 3650 is better
I checked around 5 GPU benchmarking websites
U try doing a research in this

 

I'm not saying 4570 is better, where'd I say that? Get the 3650 or better, the 4570 is weak for gaming. All it is, is a step up from integrated.

 

sory i mean 3650 is better but its below 4570 in every benchmarking test
In bench marking test 3650 is beating 4570
and you guys r saying 3650 is better
I checked around 5 GPU benchmarking websites
U try doing a research in this

 

links?

please use notebookcheck.net for checking specifications only, their benchmarks and rankings are very skewed, ask real people instead, like this forum.

 

so tel me at last which one I shud buy Dell studio 15 (256MB ATI Mobility Radeon HD 4570) or dell studio 17 (256MB ATI Mobility Radeon HD 3650)
for playing resource heavy games?

 

Neither are good for resource intensive games, period.

 

but still just tel me which is better b/w these two
or is there any other laptop at this price range of studio then suggest me

 

Well, you said in your other topic you can get an Asus. Get an Asus G50VT. It has a 9800M GS, which is a pretty powerful GPU. Still in the 1100 dollar price range.

 

Sorry bro but this laptop is not available in india
any other choice

 

Could you link us to distributors you can buy from?

 

I'm ready to buy from any where but it should be available in india
I dnt understand what u wnt to knw

 

Well, you said you can buy Asus, I suggested an Asus but you said that one is not available to you.
How do any of us have ANY idea of what is available to you? Should I blindly keep making suggestions until you say "oh yeah, I can get that one"?
Cause I'm not doing that.

Post links to the websites you can order from, and we can find you the best laptop in your budget from those places

 

I'll make ur job simpler
justmake choices b/w DELL and HP
cause these are cheapest in india

www.compareindia.com is best site for comparing gadgets in india and you can also check prices and do comparision and see if its available or not

 

Try for an HP dv6t or dv7t with the Ati 4650 then.

 

Hi.
I want to buy a laptop that has an intel X4500MHD
my desktop has geforce 7300LE and it can handle the games I want to play.
I wanted to know :
can X4500MHD run games like 7300LE?
Is it better than 7300LE?
Is it worse than 7300LE?
thx
-------------------------
Can you tell me , what Nvidia (Desktop - 8 Series) card has exactly same performance with X4500MHD?

 

That thing score around 500 in 3dmark06... Yes the x4500mhd is definitely better. The closest desktop equivalent would be the X4500HD which is basically the same thing. It still get it's pants whooped by the HD3200 though... But it'll play better than the 7300le.

 

Thx a lot
But ,
what Nvidia (Desktop - 8 Series) card has exactly same performance with X4500MHD?
I don't know much about ATI cards , and thats why I asked you for a Nvidia Card

 

An nvidia 8200, maybe? Does an 8200 desktop card even exist?

 

these are costly here for more than 1300$

 

It's an IGP but it's better than the x4500mhd ... It's almost as good as the 780g/hd3200.

 

Thats the Ati HD3650 512mb GDDR3 or the 9600M GS 512mb GDDR3?
How do they compare to each other?

 

They're pretty much the same. In different games, one may outperform the other due to game optimizations for a certain brand GPU.

 

How does the NVIDIA GT 130M compare to the ATI Mobility Radeon 4650 HD and the ATI Mobility Radeon 2600 HD?

 

130M=4650 (game dependent) >>>>> 2600

I'm pretty sure this was answered in another thread though...people need to stop double posting, especially after they've already gotten an answer.

 

Sorry about the double post. I thought I would get some more feedback in this dedicated thread.

 

The first page of this post lists the most popular graphics cards in order of power and cost.

The 2600 wasn't listed because the post only goes back so far (just like how my gefore 7000 isn't listed) in terms of graphics cards.

Also I believe the 130m is just a 9600m with high clock speeds (I might be wrong on this), which is why that isn't listed either.

 

Except it is made in 55nm process, thus can have higher clocks, less heat is produced. The chipset is same though.

 

according to this thread the ati HD3650 512mb GDDR3 is just below the nvidia 9600GT GDDR3 so why have people been telling me its just a bit less powerfull than the 9600GS when its quite a few places higher than the 9600GS on the performance list?

is this an error in the performance list?

 

Link? <ninjatext>

 

What do you mean link, i mean this thread we are posting on, "Re: UPDATED - The Mobile Graphics Card Info Page - Most GPU Qs answered"

Just go to the first page.

 

My bad, I thought you were talking about a different thread when you said "this thread".

 

The 9600M GS is the same card as the 9600M GT except it has lower clockspeeds. Upping the clockspeeds equates to a linear increase in performance. I have seen 3DMark06 benchmark results for the 9600M GT ranging from the 3900 range to the mid 5000s, so clockspeeds make a big difference. More or less the 9600M is on par with the HD 3650, there is no significant difference between the two; with both cards you are going to have a nice gaming experience.

 

Apparently nvidia 130M in Samsung R560 scores 6449. Review here in polish. Use google for translation.

 

Hello, I'm a bit confused which card is better 9600M GT DDR2 or HD3650 DDR2? Acroding to the "big chart" seems like HD3650 is better:

Nvidia GeForce 9600M-GT DDR2
Nvidia GeForce 9650M-GT DDR2
ATI Mobility Radeon HD 3650/3670
Nvidia GeForce Go7900GS
Nvidia GeForce 9600M-GT GDDR3

and acroding to the "performance video cards chart" 9600M wins:

ATI Mobility Radeon HD 3650 DDR2
Nvidia GeForce 9600M-GT DDR2/9650M-GT DDR2
ATI Mobility Radeon HD 3650 GDDR3
Nvidia GeForce 9600M-GT GDDR3

So how is it?